New Tory idea has been law for 15 years

A new Tory poster says "Let's cut benefits for those who refuse work". The policy has been law for 15 years and shows the lack of imagination on welfare reform.

David Cameron is in a corner following the Lib Dem surge. His Big Society message isn’t connecting, he doesn’t know what kind of campaign he wants to run or what kind of leader he wants to be. In truth, that has always been the problem with his ‘modernisation’ of the Tory party – but it’s becoming more apparent in the heat of electoral battle.

The latest reaction is a poster saying, “Let’s cut benefits for those who refuse work”. Wow. Great idea. The slight snag for the Tories is that this is such a revolutionary idea it has been law in its current form for about 15 years – and was the law for most of the post-First World War War period. That was until the Tories reduced conditions on benefits in the 1980s recession, because they wouldn’t increase the spending needed to run the operation.

This ‘new idea’ is contained in a “new welfare contract“, which was not even new when exactly the same policies were announced last September. Taking each one in turn, the government is already doing them! Help from day one, extra help once you’ve been out of for 6 months, reassessing all Incapacity Benefit claimants, paying private and voluntary providers for helping people into work – this is all existing policy.

The lack of originality is one thing. But the wider point is that so much of the content of the Big Society argument is based on a view of the country that is at best skewed and at worst a fantasy. What’s also depressing about the latest Tory parody is that it remains stuck in a tired 1990s ‘rights and responsibilities’ approach to welfare, when we need a new phase that offers more to people and asks more of them in return.

Tomorrow the Open Left project at Demos is publishing a new collection of papers which proposes what a new phase might look like. We call it Liberation Welfare – where people are the primary agents of change in their lives, but in conditions shaped by society.

It’s goals would be the following. Greater greater power in the hands of citizens – rather than a passive and paternalistic approach. Greater security against risks and better incentives for self-protection – rather than accepting market outcomes and regressive incentives. And greater reciprocity between citizens and practitioners at the frontline, based around individual needs – rather than a highly prescriptive, rules-based system of support.

In short, the welfare state should be more empowering and more demanding. Rather than a mutual stand off; mutual engagement and expectations.

Our collection sets out a wide range of ideas to illustrate how Liberation Welfare could work in practice. Here are four big ideas that speak to this new philosophy:

1) anyone at risk of long-term unemployment should be guaranteed decent paid work, and be expected to take it up.

2) the incentive to self-protect against income shocks should be transformed, by shifting state support for savings to people on low incomes and reducing the penalty for doing so in the benefits system.

3) we should ensure that no one who works hard ends up in poverty, through a combination of the minimum wage, a living wage in the public sector and campaigns for one in the private sector, and wage supplements (such as through the Working Tax Credit).

4) the package of support and conditions for people looking for, or preparing for, work should be more tailored to their personal circumstances.

Labour is at it’s best when it champions radical reform of both the market and the state. It’s manifesto commitments to a job guarantee for anyone unemployed for two years, a living wage for all Whitehall staff and a rising minimum wage are all shining examples of this. The Tories back neither. Indeed, not for the first time, David Cameron has been caught visiting a Future Jobs Fund employer but failing to admit that his party is committed to axing the policy. Their policy document ‘Get Britain Working‘ states clearly:

“We do not believe that subsidised temporary ‘make-work’ jobs – which Labour is providing through the Future Jobs Fund – can conceivably address the failure of the education system to prepare a generation of young people for the future.

The Tories aren’t prepared to ensure there is work for people who need it, paid at a decent rate, with the requirement to take it up. Instead they rail against a problem that doesn’t exist.

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today.

14 Responses to “New Tory idea has been law for 15 years”

  1. Bin27

    RT @leftfootfwd: New Tory idea has been law for 15 years – a more intelligent approach is needed to welfare reform http://bit.ly/cf9SNA

  2. Stephen Bond

    RT @leftfootfwd New Tory idea has been law for 15 years – a more intelligent approach is needed to welfare reform http://bit.ly/cf9SNA

  3. Stoo

    RT @leftfootfwd New Tory idea has been law for 15 years – a more intelligent approach is needed to welfare reform http://bit.ly/cf9SNA

  4. House Of Twits

    RT @leftfootfwd New Tory idea has been law for 15 years – a more intelligent approach is needed to welfare reform http://bit.ly/cf9SNA

  5. kris castle

    RT @leftfootfwd: New Tory idea has been law for 15 years – a more intelligent approach is needed to welfare reform http://bit.ly/cf9SNA

  6. Tories Drift Right with new Tactics « A Future Bear For All

    […] the poster fails to point out is that the policy is already law. But this is not a surprise from a party that in one hand wants to run a ‘positive […]

  7. nilsinela boray

    deleted that last tweet. Incorrect link. Left Foot Forward pulls rug from under new Tory poster – it's already law : http://bit.ly/aF1MsZ

  8. Phil Maylor

    "New Tory idea has been law for 15 years" http://bit.ly/coPK94 #GE2010

  9. topsy_top20k

    New Tory idea has been law for 15 years – a more intelligent approach is needed to welfare reform http://bit.ly/cf9SNA

  10. James Doran

    RT @leftfootfwd: New Tory idea has been law for 15 years http://bit.ly/cf9SNA

  11. donpaskini

    Well done – so the response to the Tories lurching to the right out of desperation is to say that Labour did it first.

    Points 2-4 of Liberation Welfare sound ok (though expensive), but this is drivel:

    “1) anyone at risk of long-term unemployment should be guaranteed decent paid work, and be expected to take it up.”

    Some people who are long term unemployed are not able to hold down a job, for a whole variety of reasons, and it is utopian authoritarianism to try to compel everyone who is unemployed into work with the threat of benefit cuts.

  12. Tory tough talk on welfare won’t help people into work | Left Foot Forward

    […] tough talk on welfare won’t help people into work As the IFS has claimed today, and Graeme Cooke discussed on Left Foot Forward yesterday, in many areas there is little between the parties on […]

  13. David Jones

    donpaskini,

    “Well done – so the response to the Tories lurching to the right out of desperation is to say that Labour did it first.”

    It’s been law for 15 years – Labour have only been in government for 13.

Leave a Reply