Osborne calls for “honest debate” while manipulating the facts

George Osborne today outlines that "Voters deserve an honest debate and a real choice". But he continue to make false claims about the impact of Britain's debt.

In an article for the Daily Telegraph this morning, George Osborne outlines that “Voters deserve an honest debate and a real choice”. Why then does he continue to make false claims about the state of the economy while refusing to set out what he would do to reduce the deficit more quickly?

Central to Osborne’s article is the “riskiness of sovereign debt and the sustainability of public finances.” He makes a series of assertions that cannot be backed up:

“Before Sweden started dealing with their debts in the Nineties, it faced a market penalty of 4.5 per cent. Britain is borrowing more than Greece, and more than Sweden was”

The yield on a 10-year bond Greek 10 year bonds yield is currently 5.79% while the UK’s is 3.80%. So clearly the market is not lumping Britain in with Greece.

“If the Bank of England stops buying government bonds next year, as is expected, it believes market interest rates will rise almost another percentage point on top of that.”

A rise in one percentage point would put interest rates at 4.8%. But this is well below the average of the last twenty years (6.5%) and in line with the average of the last ten years (4.7%). George Osborne needs to explain how a bond yield of 4.8% represents a disaster, particularly since the yield was over 10% when Cameron was a special adviser in the Treasury in the early 1990s.

“If Britain follows Greece, the interest bill on a £150,000 mortgage could go up by more than £200 a month.”

The Chart below shows Bank of England data on the standard variable interest rate (SVR) on mortgages. One year ago the SVR was 6.34% while today it is 3.91%. This means that the monthly interest bill on a £150,000 mortgage is over £300 lower today than it was a year ago. In April 1997 the SVR was 7.22%. So last time the Tories were in power, the monthly mortgage rate was over £400 higher than today.

On the wider economy, Osborne is just as inaccurate.

“youth unemployment – which Gordon Brown pledged to abolish – is at an all-time high”

But as this blog pointed out last week, records only began in 1992 while the 1980s recession was far worse for young people.

“For the first time in my adult life, people are talking about leaving the country.”

Does he not remember Paul Daniels, Frank Bruno or Andrew Lloyd Webber?

Osborne, of course, is still to set out how the Conservatives would reduce the deficit further and faster than the halving over four years proposed by Labour. Indeed, Osborne’s article doesn’t even please his own side. As Tim Montgomerie of Conservative Home opines this morning:

“[George Osborne] is yet to announce a deficit reduction plan. We have had some austerity measures from the Tories but only a fraction of what is going to be necessary.”

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

22 Responses to “Osborne calls for “honest debate” while manipulating the facts”

  1. Alex Ross

    More #torylies from George Osborne, re: youth unemployment, sovereign debt and the economy: http://bit.ly/8NMfO4 Hat-tip: @leftfootfwd

  2. Ben Cooper

    RT @leftfootfwd: George Osborne wants an "honest debate" but can't help himself manipulating the data on debt http://bit.ly/8NMfO4

  3. Anon E Mouse

    Will – Why not provide a graph with the number of new mortgages taken out over that period.

    No one can get a mortgage any more so the graph is worthless and could be considered misleading in the context.

    Napoleon said “Lies, damn lies and statistics”. Seems we learn nothing in life.

    With the Tories back up with a 17 point lead again – why doesn’t LFF start publishing articles that Labour campaigners can use on the doorstep, positive stories to use in messages instead of this negative stuff about the opposition.

    People aren’t listening to Labour any more and with this type of negative stuff one can see why.

  4. Joanna

    um, so you haven’t actually identified anything George Osborne wrote that isn’t true, or that could even be characterised as “twisting the facts”. he is very clearly warning about would could happen if Labour win the election, not what is happening now

  5. Liz McShane

    Anon – that long list is a good starting point!

Comments are closed.