Comment: Corbyn’s win could be an opportunity to tackle extremism

The new Labour leader will present a challenge to Islamists who identify UK foreign policy as a motivating factor



Given that Jeremy Corbyn has been roundly criticised for his ‘friendship‘ with two Islamist extremist and terrorist organisations, Hamas and Hezbollah, and lambasted for peculiarly drawing moral equivalence between ISIS and the USA, it may seem odd for the political liaison officer of a non-partisan counter-extremism think tank to welcome him as the new Labour leader. But I’m going to do it anyway.

Jeremy Corbyn, beyond these statements, is well-known for opposing the establishment (whether government or opposition), and is chair of Stop the War Coalition, vice-chair of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament and a patron of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign. And now he has a 59 per cent strong mandate to lead the second largest party in British politics.

Islamist organisations have repeatedly identified Western foreign policy towards Iraq and Palestine as chief motivating factors for their movement. Some, including those mentioned earlier, have even used this to justify violence to defend Muslims they see as oppressed in these places and others.

If we believe those who tell us that foreign policy grievances, rather than the Islamist ideology, is the most significant driving factor for radicalisation then there is now an exciting opportunity to respond, as we have a Labour Party led by a man vocal in his shared opposition to this foreign policy.

And if we believe that stopping violence is the priority, then having Her Majesty’s Opposition being led by a man who has personally adopted these causes and is committed to doing so through democratic institutions, then this is good for counter-extremism.

Of course, if radicalisation is actually more complex than a petulant reaction to foreign policy, and is in fact made more likely by the normalisation of an Islamist worldview that pits Western civilisation with Muslims all across the globe; the prevalence of an ideology that politically exploits Islam to further the interests of several privileged leaders; and widespread identity crisis among young British Muslims due to a lack of integration, then perhaps we won’t see any trends reverse with Corbyn’s ascension to Labour leader.

I hope that in return for his party defending his democratic mandate, Corbyn will take democratic culture forward and lead not just with ‘straight-talking, honest politics’, but also the human rights values that underpin our state and society. ‘Social justice and equality’ are excellent things to which Corbyn aspires, and I think that as he progresses, he will see these values in Islam but not in Islamist extremism.

A ‘new kind of politics’ should mean a commitment to greater gender equality and a pledge to enfranchise young people and ethnic minorities who many think feel disenfranchised by the ‘male, pale and stale’ make up of those iconic green benches.

I see this problem mirrored in Britain’s Muslim communities where too often ‘gatekeepers of the community’ have stifled the voices of the young, the female and the minorities, and prevented progress. If Corbyn is serious about his pledge, then I’d encourage him to take his approach to the Commons to Muslim communities as well.

And to these Muslim communities, you too have an opportunity. Get involved in politics, follow the leader that opposes the War in Iraq, and join the party that has elected a British Muslim as its candidate for the London Mayoral Election next year.

Or stand up and decide that you don’t need to be defined by foreign policy and your faith, and join a different party because of its stance on housing, climate change or inheritance tax, depending on what is important to you.

I hope that Corbyn will see that with his new power comes the diplomatic responsibility of leading the opposition, and this means considering the detriment of inviting extremists into Whitehall. You can meet who you like when you’re a backbencher; it is slightly different when all of your decisions will be considered indicative of your party’s position, and may be used by foreign governments to pressure the UK diplomatically.

There is nothing particularly left or right about counter-extremism, so Corbyn must be encouraged to think critically on this agenda in his new role.

Too often, the regressive left present themselves as fellow travellers with Islamist extremism and don’t stand up for universal human rights, instead favouring a dogmatic, populist form of identity politics more traditionally associated with the political or theocratic far-right.

I hope Corbyn does not fall into this intellectual laziness. He may disagree with Cameron’s economics and Blair’s foreign policy, but he would do well to learn from their deeper understanding of radicalisation.

I too will be reaching out to the new Labour leader, as I think it is vitally important for the opposition to hold the government to account on progressive counter-extremism, campaign for a clear balance between counter-terrorism and human rights, and ensure our national security without compromising our civil liberties.

Jonathan Russell is political liaison officer at Quilliam

12 Responses to “Comment: Corbyn’s win could be an opportunity to tackle extremism”

  1. Mark

    Hmm, that’s the definition of optimism. I can’t see it myself, but then again, I’m a pessimist. I can only imagine him being completely against the latest “tougher” stance on extremism, and siding with groups like CAGE. Don’t forget that he spoke at a rally in 2006, which was demonstrating against the Danish cartoons being drawn (not against the killings that occurred). He said something along the lines of “we demand that we respect each other’s faiths.” Well, if you count secular freedoms as “faith” in terms of them being sacrosanct, he was effectively arguing (demanding) that those freedoms “respect” religious blasphemy laws by backing down. That, I reckon, is the direction he would take.

  2. Tony Fitzpatrick

    We shall see: I moved to the Lib Dems after the election: more in hope than expectation. By their friends shall ye know them! I hope you are right and I am wrong.

  3. David Lindsay

    I am told that many a Lib Dem is horrified at the prospect of an influx of the Blairite wing of the Labour Party. But the Government will regret starting off with the Trade Union Bill, thereby uniting Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour Party on Day One. It will need the support of the Blairites when it condescends to seek parliamentary approval for its already ongoing war in Syria. And it certainly won’t be getting that support from the Lib Dems. Not these days.

  4. Nick

    i would think that under JC leadership those who likely to go to Syria to join extremists will refrain from doing so

    Just as they would if the late Micheal foot were leader


    Corbyn is just an Islamic puppet muppet.

  6. steroflex

    Negotiating from weakness (he is going to get rid of all our defences and allow Iran to go ahead towards nuclear power) and blundering into a religious conflict when you are an avowed atheist does not bode well.
    Have you read,Jonathan “Not in God’s Name” by Rabbi Jonathan Sacks? Marvellous.

  7. Rick

    His support for islamofascist ‘friends’ will be an encouragement for the terrorists.

  8. Eoireitum

    Yes, because Tim Farron’s the man….something of a Hobson’s choice for us Blairites. Never been so depressed over the options for centrist Labour.
    Depressing first 48hrs too. Oh well – guess I’ll have to work from within.

  9. Steve Larson

    A lot of Islamists state they do not care about foreign policy, jihad for its own sake and reward.

    Things like speaking to political meetings where the sexes are segregated have done as much to damage society and reward extremist behaviour, even when not violent. Look at events in lead up to election.

    Pretending that Islamic extremism is always a reaction to the actions of the West is a dead end and Western centric view.

  10. Peter Swann

    I agree with Jonathon. Things are never quite as simple as many, including our Government, want us to think. Extremists in Syria etc will always find an excuse to justify and continue their actions. Didn’t they murder the first elected Lebanese leader a couple of decades or so ago? However, the fact remains that Jeremy Corbyn is irrelevant until he wins a general election. He will not do that unless he brings on board all of the Labour Party including the so-called ‘Blairites’ of whom I am (was?) one. Blairites also want social justice inside and outside of Britain. However, this is a two way thing. Those former ministers and shadow ministers who refused to serve in Corbyn’s shadow cabinet should be ashamed of themselves. Maybe they form part of the vested interests that the truely socialist Blairites will always oppose? Lets all get behind our democratically selected leader and win power. Then our voice will count. Those who don’t want to do that should leave politics to those who genuinely believe in democracy – whatever result it produces.

  11. Selohesra

    You say Govt will regret starting with Trade Union Bill as will unite Labour – actually I think they will be delighted to unite Labour – they want to keep Corbyn in place up to the next election. If you think he has been given a tough ride by the media so far just wait until the next election gets into full swing.

  12. C A

    There’s more chance of the Saudis building a shul in Mecca.

Leave a Reply