Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise

George Osborne set out yesterday that the VAT rise to 20% would be permanent. Left Foot Forward sets out five facts about the regressive and avoidable tax rise.

VAT has risen four times under the Tories

The rightwing press are surprisingly alone today in reporting remarks yesterday by George Osborne to The Spectator. The Chancellor said:

“The VAT rise is not temporary. It can’t be. We are talking about a totally different scale of revenue and the VAT rise is a structural change to the tax system to deal with a structural deficit.”

Left Foot Forward sets out some facts about the tax rise.

 

1. The VAT rise is avoidable

According to the Budget red book, The increase in VAT from 17.5 per cent to 20 per cent raises £13.5 billion by 2014-15. But cuts to income tax, national insurance, corporation tax, and council tax cost £12.4bn. Net of Tory tax cuts, the VAT rise brings in just £1.1bn. New OBR boss, Robert Chote, said in May:

“When Mr Osborne said that “the years of debt and spending” made the £13 billion increase in VAT unavoidable you might just as well say it was his desire to cut other taxes that made it so”

 

2. VAT is a regressive tax

Using data from the ONS, the Fabian Society’s Tim Horton has said, “The richest 10% pay one in every 25 pounds of their income in VAT; the poorest 10% pay one in every seven pounds as VAT”. There is a debate about whether VAT remains regressive when measured against households’ spending rather than income. But on Tax Research UK, Richard Murphy has explained why this is only true if the poor have savings, access to borrowing, and the same consumption patterns as the rich. As The Guardian‘s Aditya Chakrabortty has concluded, “since VAT takes no account of one’s ability to pay, it cannot be called progressive.” Even the TaxPayers’ Alliance accept that “VAT hits the poor twice as hard as the rich“.

 

3. VAT hits the north harder than the south

Research published last week by the marketing firm, Acxiom, shows that there is a north-south divide in the impact of the VAT rise. The study showed that London and the South East were more resilient to the tax rise than other regions. Among the ten places least affected by the VAT rise were the Tory heartlands of West Berkshire, Buckinghamshire, Surrey, Hertfordshire, Wokingham, Windsor and Maidenhead, and Oxfordshire where David Cameron’s Witney seat is situated. Meanwhile Hull, Blaenau Gwent, Stoke-on-Trent, Leicester, Middlesbrough, Orkney, Eilean Siar, Ceredigion, Merthyr Tydfil, and Gwynedd will be worst affected.

 

4. The increase is the fourth rise in VAT by a Tory government

As Duncan Weldon has shown:

“When VAT was introduced, by a Conservative government in 1973, it was set at 10 per cent. Geoffrey Howe, despite promising not to “double VAT” in the 1979 election campaign, raised it to 15 per cent. It was then increased to 17.5 per cent by Norman Lamont.

“In the 37 years since its introduction, VAT has risen from 10 per cent to 20 per cent. Meanwhile the basic rate of income tax has fallen from 30 per cent to 20 per cent.”

 

5. The VAT rise is a broken promise

On April 1st, David Cameron told Sky News, “our plans don’t involve an increase in VAT” while after the election in mid-May, the new Prime Minister told Andrew Marr that a VAT rise was “not something we plan to do“. Next Left saw it coming and raised the spectre of the “Geoffrey Howe dodge” in April in honour of a previous Tory broken promise on VAT.

As with tuition fees, the Liberal Democrats campaigned heavily on the issue of VAT publishing posters declaring “Tory VAT bombshell: You’d pay £389 more a year in VAT under the Conservatives“. An example, perhaps, of sticking a bit too closely to their pledge of “no more broken promises“.

149 Responses to “Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise”

  1. Jonathan Davis

    @b_utton You seen this on Left Foot Forward? http://bit.ly/et7atr

  2. Bethan Hamilton

    RT @jonathand: @b_utton You seen this on Left Foot Forward? http://bit.ly/et7atr

  3. Mary Hill

    RT @wdjstraw: Five facts about the VAT rise (from the @leftfootfwd archive) http://bit.ly/hSb1KK

  4. No UK Shock Doctrine

    RT @davidwearing: RT @leftfootfwd: Five facts about Osborne's permanent VAT rise http://bit.ly/eQOHTt

  5. Alex Richman

    RT @wdjstraw: Five facts about the VAT rise (from the @leftfootfwd archive) http://bit.ly/hSb1KK

  6. Catherine Deadly

    RT@lipsticklori RT via lots of people: Five things about the VAT rise (from the @leftfootfwd archive) http://bit.ly/hSb1KK

  7. Eric T Dickinson

    RT @johnprescott: Five facts about the VAT rise via @leftfootfwd http://bit.ly/hSb1KK

  8. Jess Green

    RT @johnprescott: Five facts about the VAT rise via @leftfootfwd http://bit.ly/hSb1KK

  9. JAMES ILES

    RT @johnprescott: Five facts about the VAT rise via @leftfootfwd http://bit.ly/hSb1KK

  10. Alex Richman

    @HenryJFoy @Petercampbell1 "Even the TaxPayers’ Alliance accept that VAT hits the poor twice as hard as the rich" http://bit.ly/hdJncQ

  11. Chris Patmore

    RT @noUKcuts: RT @davidwearing: RT @leftfootfwd: Five facts about Osborne's permanent VAT rise http://bit.ly/eQOHTt

  12. Jonathan Walker

    RT @wdjstraw: Five facts about the VAT rise (from the @leftfootfwd archive) http://bit.ly/hSb1KK

  13. Clair

    RT @lipsticklori: RT via lots of people: Five facts about the VAT rise (from the @leftfootfwd archive) http://bit.ly/hSb1KK

  14. Gareth Douce

    RT @johnprescott: Five facts about the VAT rise via @leftfootfwd http://bit.ly/hSb1KK

  15. Angela Pateman

    RT @michael__ellis: Interesting read RT @wdjstraw: Five facts about the VAT rise (from the @leftfootfwd archive) http://bit.ly/hSb1KK (v …

  16. Tweetminster

    "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left Foot Forward

  17. Luke Pollard

    Another brillaint post – RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left Foot Forward

  18. Max

    RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left Foot Forward

  19. James Lipscombe

    RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left Foot Forward

  20. Patches

    RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left Foot Forward

  21. David Hardman

    RT @leftfootfwd: Five facts about Osborne's permanent VAT rise http://bit.ly/eQOHTt

  22. Tim Moore

    RT @LukePollard: Another brillaint post – RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left …

  23. Jordan Newell

    RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr

  24. James Anthony

    This makes for grim reading. RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left Foot Forward

  25. Lex_Bear

    RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left Foot Forward

  26. Jason Kitcat

    No.1 – the rise is avoidable RT @tweetminster "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left Foot Forward

  27. Jon Dennis

    RT @jimboeth: This makes for grim reading. RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Lef …

  28. Thom Brown

    RT @jasonkitcat: No.1 – the rise is avoidable RT @tweetminster "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Le …

  29. Carlos

    RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left Foot Forward

  30. David Hartery

    @conorjh http://bit.ly/fltzHr Dunno if you remember our chat about VAT, but this is interesting.

  31. Andrew Burnie

    RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left Foot Forward

  32. Gareth Douce

    RT @jordannewell: RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr

  33. cutsandgrazes dotcom

    RT @davidwearing: RT @leftfootfwd: Five facts about Osborne's permanent VAT rise http://bit.ly/eQOHTt

  34. cutsandgrazes dotcom

    RT @davidwearing: RT @leftfootfwd: Five facts about Osborne's permanent VAT rise http://bit.ly/eQOHTt

  35. How Cameron and Clegg were against VAT rise before they were for it | Liberal Conspiracy

    […] broken promises? You betcha. As Left Foot Forward pointed out earlier, there are alternatives. […]

  36. Osborne’s financial pain begins as VAT hike hits | Left Foot Forward

    […] to know where Labour would have found the £13bn that he claims the VAT rise will deliver. As Left Foot Forward and numerous eminent economists have argued, instead of opting for a 77:23 split of spending cuts […]

  37. Bermondsey Labour

    RT @leftfootfwd: Five facts about Osborne's permanent VAT rise http://bit.ly/eQOHTt

  38. Vicky Heywood

    Great article on Left Foot Forward? – 'VAT Five facts' http://bit.ly/et7atr (via @jonathand)

  39. Vicky Heywood

    Great article on Left Foot Forward 16th Dec – 'VAT Five facts' http://bit.ly/et7atr (via @jonathand)

  40. Double.Karma

    RT @davidwearing: RT @leftfootfwd: Five facts about Osborne's permanent VAT rise http://bit.ly/eQOHTt

  41. Steve

    RT @leftfootfwd: Five facts about Osborne's permanent VAT rise http://bit.ly/eQOHTt

  42. Elaine S

    RT @LukePollard: Another brillaint post – RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left …

  43. Emily Peabody

    RT @davidwearing: RT @leftfootfwd: Five facts about Osborne's permanent VAT rise http://bit.ly/eQOHTt

  44. Patricia Walker

    RT @LukePollard: Another brillaint post – RT @tweetminster: "Five facts about Osborne’s permanent VAT rise" http://bit.ly/fltzHr – Left …

  45. Richard

    “a marginal increase…”? So a 14.3% increase in VAT is marginal, is it Paul?

  46. PCS MOD Group

    Five facts about Osborne's permanent VAT rise http://bit.ly/eQOHTt

  47. john smith

    RT @johnprescott: Five facts about the VAT rise via @leftfootfwd http://bit.ly/hSb1KK

  48. Look Left – Former Labour MP sent down for expenses fraud | Left Foot Forward

    […] only raises expectations for calamitous policies like the rapid cuts to public services or the ideological rise in VAT which was only necessary to pay for tax cuts to corporation tax, council tax, national […]

  49. Nine economists tell George Osborne how to fix the country | Left Foot Forward

    […] Pissarides, the 2010 Nobel prize winner, argues that Osborne should cut VAT back to 17.5 per cent. He tells Osborne that: Deficit reduction is best done with spending cuts when the […]

Leave a Reply