Cameron compares British politics with India

David Cameron says India's Electoral Commission is 20-times better than Britain's, but what do the facts say

A ballot box

David Cameron, in a key-note speech today on cutting the cost of politics, compared India’s Electoral Commission with that of Britain’s, impyling that it was 20-times better value.

A detailed look at the levels of corruption in each country, however, might lead one to a different conclusion.

In the Indian elections in June this year:

– 150 of the 543 MPs elected were facing criminal charges;

– 17 have been charged with murder;

– 19 have been charged with attempted murder;

– Three MPs face multiple charges of murder;

– One of these, Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury – MP for Baharampur, West Bengal – faces three counts of murder, as well as charges of voluntarily causing hurt, wrongful restraint, criminal trespass and criminal intimidation;

– Various other MPs have been charged with slave trading, child prostitution, domestic violence, forgery, rioting, arson, harbouring an offender, extortion, obscene acts and bribery;

– And of the 64 candidates standing in by-elections this month, 15 have charges of murder and attempted murder hanging over them.

4 Responses to “Cameron compares British politics with India”

  1. Ben WP

    I suspect someone in CCHQ will now be thinking that their cute line about Indian politics was now not so cute….

  2. Worth a look – six political articles we like 

    […] Shamik Das at the new Left Foot Forward website says that David Cameron should think twice before arguing, as he did yesterday, that the Electoral Commission should learn from its Indian counterpart. […]

  3. New Indian president could put an end to ongoing corruption | Left Foot Forward

    […] Shamik Das reported following the elections in […]

Leave a Reply