Right-Wing Watch

The rise of climate inaction: When political short-termism trumps the planet

Is the right driving a retreat on climate policy?

Gabrielle Pickard-Whitehead · 8 mins read

The UN’s annual Conference of the Parties (COP) has concluded for another year. As delegates fly home from Antalya, questions remain over the commitment of the 197 countries and EU members that gather annually to assess global warming and agree collective action.

The empty chairs at COP31 spoke volumes. Several European leaders chose instead to head to Dublin for the first EU summit devoted entirely to AI. Ireland’s Taoiseach had the best alibi of all – he was hosting it.

While Germany, France, Italy, Denmark, Sweden, Ireland, the Netherlands, Canada and Japan may not have followed the US in abandoning the Paris Agreement, their absence at COP suggests that confronting the climate emergency is no longer considered a sufficiently pressing political priority.

“The future of AI is apparently worth showing up for, while the future of the planet can wait,” wrote Climate Action Network International.

Andy Burnham, meanwhile, made a brief appearance in Antalya, promising to “drive forward” progress on climate action. Downing Street insisted his visit was intended to send a “clear message” that the UK remained committed to tackling global warming.

But Burnham’s position on the climate has attracted criticism.

Green campaigners and policy experts have accused Burnham of paying “lip service” to climate action, presiding over a “rapid downward trajectory” and backtracking on measures designed to tackle global warming.

“The positive messaging and rhetoric on the international stage is not necessarily being matched through domestic actions,” David Walsh, head of public affairs at WWF UK, told the FT.

A Labour MP shared similar concerns: “It’s a polarising topic,” they said. “He’d clearly rather focus on ‘everyday fixes’ and the NHS and the ‘Burnham brand’.”

When climate action becomes an electoral liability

Faced with pressure over household bills, living costs and economic insecurity, progressive leaders appear tempted to put ambitious environmental policies on the back burner in favour of immediate, more electorally attractive promises.

Burnham’s emerging approach is a case in point. Recent decisions have disappointed environmental campaigners, including approving a new North Sea gas field, extending the fuel duty freeze, floating the possibility of reducing electric vehicle targets and, most recently, cutting support for heat pumps.

As The Conversation notes:

“His plan has a razor-sharp focus on consumers, and a by-product of this might be to cut fossil fuel use too. But along the way, he looks like he is ready to drop any decision that could make the broader agenda unpopular.”

The danger is that by treating climate policies as an electoral liability, progressive politicians concede the argument to those who have spent years portraying environmental protection as a burden.

Just this week, environmental charities Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace warned that approving the Rosebank oil field and expanding Heathrow Airport would undermine the UK’s credibility as it seeks to establish itself as a global leader on climate security.

Their criticism followed the appointment of Madeleine Alessandri as the UK’s special representative for climate security at COP31.

Rosie Downes, head of campaigns at Friends of the Earth, welcomed the appointment but warned that it could appear “tokenistic” if international rhetoric was not matched by domestic action.

Approving new oil and gas developments, a third Heathrow runway or watering down electric vehicle targets would “fly in the face” of the prime minister’s pledge to usher in a “new era of British leadership” on climate, she said.

Supporters of drilling the Rosebank oil and Jackdaw gas fields argue increased domestic production would boost jobs, tax revenues and energy security. Some also claim it would bring down household energy bills.

Launching her party’s Get Britain Drilling Now Bill earlier this year, Kemi Badenoch declared that drilling was “the only way we can protect families from rising bills, keep the cost of energy down for business, and control inflation.”

Yet there is substantial evidence that more North Sea oil and gas extraction would not automatically translate into cheaper energy bills.

Analysis by the Oxford Smith School found that a UK powered entirely by renewables could save households up to £441 a year. By contrast, maximising North Sea oil and gas extraction would save just £16 – £82 annually, and only if tax revenues were redistributed to households to offset their bills.

Dr Anupama Sen, co-author of the report and head of policy engagement at the Smith School, said the idea that draining the North Sea would make the UK more energy secure or significantly save on household bills “is sheer fantasy.”

Is the right driving a retreat on climate policy? 

The current political climate raises the question: how much of this retreat from climate action is driven by political pressure from the right?

Reform UK, which just six months ago appeared on course to lead a right-wing populist government, has made scrapping net zero a clear policy intention.

Its promise to cut energy bills by £250 rests on expanding domestic energy production and scrapping policies it claims “drive bills higher.”

It’s a line that’s repeated with vigour in the right-wing press.

“Tories imposed Net Zero and boasted about it – don’t be fooled by new energy policies,” blared Richard Tice’s Express headline in August, as Britain was in the middle of an unprecedented heatwave made more likely and intense, as climate scientists agreed, by climate change.

The historical record is worth remembering. Theresa May’s Conservative government formally introduced the UK’s 2050 net-zero target into law in 2019. The original Climate Change Act, passed under Labour in 2008, had committed the UK to an 80 percent reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.

Kemi Badenoch, meanwhile, has pledged to repeal the Climate Change Act and replace it with a “cheap energy” strategy should the Conservatives win the next election. This would go considerably further than abandoning the net-zero target, dismantling a cornerstone of British climate and energy policy.

With Reform advocating the abolition of net zero and the Conservatives threatening to repeal the legislation underpinning climate action, the political pressure on Labour to dilute its environmental commitments is mounting, and the danger is that rather than challenging this narrative, progressive leaders are accommodating it.

The cost of political short-termism

There are lessons here from Boris Johnson’s premiership. His enthusiasm for net zero was wrapped in a vision of a green industrial revolution, promising decades of economic growth through investment in new technologies.

As The Conversation notes, that vision has political appeal, but the transition becomes more difficult when people encounter its immediate costs.

Burnham’s consumer-first approach reflects a different calculation: prioritising immediate affordability and electoral appeal over measures whose economic and environmental benefits may take longer to materialise.

The challenge for progressive politicians is to demonstrate that tackling climate change and improving living standards are not competing objectives. A transition that makes energy, transport and housing more affordable can deliver both.

And this short-termism is not confined to British politics.

As we touched on in RWW last week, Spain’s forthcoming election could have significant consequences for Europe’s climate ambitions. Under Pedro Sánchez, Spain has become a leading advocate of the green transition, supported by substantial EU funding and regulatory reforms.

A victory for the right, potentially bringing together the conservative People’s Party (PP), Catalan pro-independence party Junts and far-right Vox, could deliver a major blow to climate policy. Vox has already called for elements of the European Green Deal to be dismantled.

“A thriving economy, a model green transition, social advances – Spain’s PM shouldn’t be in trouble. Yet he is, and it’s a lesson for progressives everywhere,” said Paolo Gerbaudo, senior researcher at the Complutense University of Madrid.

The lesson is that policy achievements alone do not guarantee political support. Economic growth and social reform matter, but voters also need to see and feel improvements in their everyday lives.

That is a legitimate political challenge. But it should prompt progressive leaders to make the case for a fairer green transition, not retreat from it.

Climate denial, repression and the far-right backlash

According to the Climate Action Tracker’s 2026 Global Update, progress in slowing global warming has flatlined for five consecutive years, with positive and negative actions cancelling one another out.

Geopolitical conflicts, economic pressures and the rise of far-right movements have all contributed to shifting attention away from the green transition.

Academic Andreas Malm told BBC Radio 4 that the rise of the far right has shifted the balance of forces in climate politics.

“What you have in parts of Europe and other parts of the world is the rise and rise and rise of the far right that says that “no it’s not climate that’s the problem, the problem is all of these non white people who are in our countries and we should get them out,” and it has completing shifted the balance of forces in climate politics,” said Malm. 

Donald Trump has repeatedly questioned established climate science, previously describing climate change as a Chinese-created hoax and a “con job.” In Europe, leaders like Italy’s Giorgia Meloni and France’s Marine Le Pen have challenged aspects of European climate policy.

And across Europe, including the UK, governments have tightened laws and policing around climate protests.

In Britain, the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 and Public Order Act 2023 expanded police powers and criminalised certain forms of disruptive protest and infrastructure blockades.

Four Just Stop Oil campaigners received four-year prison sentences for their non-violent direct action on the M25 in 2022. During the trial, the judge instructed the jury to disregard evidence relating to the climate emergency, while the defendants were prevented from discussing climate breakdown in depth when defending their actions.

Research published this year suggests criminalising climate protest may be counterproductive, increasing rather than diminishing activists’ determination to undertake disruptive demonstrations.

Between 2019 and 2024, 17 percent of climate protests in the UK resulted in arrests, compared with an international average of 6.3 percent.

“These kinds of actions are counterproductive as they alienate people from the state,” said Dr Nicole Tausch of the University of St Andrews, who was part of the research team.

Climate action slipping down the agenda

The evidence points to a widening gap between climate commitments and political action. The Climate Action Tracker reports five years of stagnation in efforts to slow global warming, while governments continue to approve fossil fuel developments, reconsider green targets and restrict climate protest.

The political backdrop is increasingly hostile. Trump continues to challenge climate science, European far-right parties are campaigning against green policies, and even progressive politicians are showing greater reluctance to defend measures that might prove unpopular.

The challenge for leaders such as Burnham is not just to reconcile the green transition with legitimate concerns about the cost of living, but to demonstrate how ‘going green’ can actually improve living standards. With energy security, household affordability and climate security increasingly interconnected, postponing action risks making all three problems harder and more expensive to resolve.

Gabrielle Pickard-Whitehead is author of Right-Wing Watch

Left Foot Forward doesn't have the backing of big business or billionaires. We rely on the kind and generous support of ordinary people like you.

You can support hard-hitting journalism that holds the right to account, provides a forum for debate among progressives, and covers the stories the rest of the media ignore. Donate today.

Donate today
Scroll to Top