Robin Hood Tax gains momentum – on the continent

Tony Burke writes about the calls from a leading German Trade Unionist to introduce a Robin Hood tax in Germany, and to deal with the discrepancy between taxes on earned and unearned income.


The German trade union movement has demanded that Germany’s richest citizens help with the countries debt crisis and tax burden which is now falling on working people.

At a recent joint press conference with chancellor Angela Merkel, Michael Sommer, the president of the powerful German Confederation of Trade Unions (Deutscher Gewerkschaftsbund – aka DGB) demanded a greater financial contribution from Germany’s rich and the tax burden to be increased on the countries wealthy.

The DGB is the union umbrella organization and represents seven million workers across Germany’s eight industrial unions.

The German economy minister Phillip Rösler is expected to revise growth estimates for 2012 in January from the official forecast for growth of one per cent for 2012.

Wolfgang Franz, the head of a panel of government economic advisers, said he expected growth of about 0.5 per cent next year, half the earlier prediction. “But I do not fear a recession – certainly not one as strong as in 2009 when GDP shrank by about five per cent,” Franz said.

In addition Angela Merkel hinted that she may re-introduce short time working subsidies in 2012 to help manufacturing industry. However, German car makers BMW, Daimler and Audi asked workers to cut short their holidays because of full order books and the German Electrical and Electronic Manufacturers’ Association said it expected growth of five per cent and sales amounting to €190 billion.

It is against this background that German unions continue to put pressure on their government to introduce more financial measures including a new stimulus package to help boost the economy.

At the height of the economic crisis in 2009 the DGB called for the introduction of a financial transaction tax (Robin Hood tax) and Sommer once again urged Merkel to introduce the tax arguing that a stock market sales tax, levied on the sale of shares and derivatives, could be introduced as a curb on high risk speculation and would also generate increased revenue for the state.

Sommer told Merkel that the tax would affect only financial speculators, given that the more an investor buys or sells stocks and shares, the more tax they would then have to pay whilst long-term investors, who provide stability to the German economy, would only feel a limited effect of the tax.

DGB calculations show that imposing a tax rate of 0.1 per cent on all transactions conducted on the stock market could generate as much as €13.5 billion a year for the German government.

Arguing that the current financial and economic crisis is not primarily a debt crisis, but a crisis of state revenues, Sommer said that it was no wonder that the state lacks money – given the successive tax cuts that have been introduced over the course of the past 10 to 15 years.

According to Sommer, if the year 2000 tax laws were still in operation in Germany, then the state would have additional revenues this year of around €50 billion and there would be no new debt today.

Sommer also argued for the introduction of a wealth tax on the rich and for an increase in inheritance tax in Germany. He challenged the current situation in Germany, where well-paid employees pay significant amounts in income tax, while individuals that do not work and live on income derived from capital pay only 25 per cent tax.

He called for the abolition of that special rate, or for a dramatic increase in the existing withholding tax rate (the amount of tax retained directly by the employer or by the bank before the earnings are paid out). Sommer said that the 32 per cent rate proposed by the German Social Democrats (SPD) was “a first step in the right direction”.

It will be interesting to see if the continuing pressure from the DGB and Germany’s manufacturing and service based unions such as IG Metal, Ver.di and the Chemical workers union IGBCE can ensure that the German government leads the field in Europe by introducing a financial transactions tax.

See also:

Cameron didn’t sign EU deal because it’s not in the interests of the one per centShamik Das, December 9th 2011

Osborne starts to panic about the chance of a Robin Hood TaxOwen Tudor, November 9th 2011

Osborne in public: “I am not against Tobin taxes”; in private: “He remains unconvinced”Alex Hern, November 9th 2011

On the Financial Transaction Tax, why is Osborne on the side of the one per cent?Shamik Das, November 2nd 2011

Robin Hood Tax would lead to calmer marketsSimon Chouffot, August 6th 2011

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

26 Responses to “Robin Hood Tax gains momentum – on the continent”

  1. Anonymous

    We have it here and it isn’t working.

    Government taxes people on minimum wage 2.5K in NI and Income tax, and then gives it to people in Westminster on benefits. Some receive 170K a year in benefits (not on ICB too).

    It’s called the reverse Robin Hood tax, as favoured by multiple home owning Poly Toynbee

  2. Anonymous

    Robin Hood Tax would lead to calmer markets


    Completely the opposite. If the consensus is that a stock is overvalued, then there are no speculators to take the stock off your hands. It’s going to fall like the proverbial stone, and quite likely to well below fair value.

    If a stock is in free fall, small transaction costs don’t matter. 0.05% against a profit of 50-100%? I’d pay it.

    Why not go for a transparent Tobin Tax? 1 pound every time you use a cash point.

  3. Anonymous

    DGB calculations show that imposing a tax rate of 0.1 per cent on all transactions conducted on the stock market could generate as much as €13.5 billion a year for the German government.


    So taking more money out of the economy is good?

    How about cutting spending? That takes money out of the economy. That’s got to be good too.

    [Neither does. It just moves it from productive areas to wasteful areas]

  4. Murph

    Robin Hood Tax gains momentum – on the continent, writes @unitetheunion's @tonyburke2010:

  5. TUCGlobal

    Unite's @TonyBurke2010 reports on union support for the #RHT in Germany If only Cameron was as pro-FTT as Merkel

Comments are closed.