Cameron defends circus animals ban farce

The prime minister sought to draw the sting out of the circus animals ban row today, insisting the government position was very similar to that of Mark Pritchard.

The prime minister sought to draw the sting out of the circus animals ban row today, jesting about having “been through the hoops”, “walked the tightropes” and “sent in the clowns” while addressing the lobby at the European Union big tent summit in Brussels this lunchtime. It follows the successful Commons motion calling for an outright ban yesterday, which was driven through by Tory MP Mark Pritchard, despite the, erm, gentle cajoling of Number 10.

Responding to a question from Sky’s Joey Jones, Mr Cameron insisted:

“There’s not that much difference between the government position and the motion. We’re minded to have a ban but need to clear some obstacles. We’re not a million miles away – though everyone could support language that was more workable…

“It’s a pity we couldn’t close the gap, and sort out the arguments about technicalities”

Of Pritchard’s claims of heavyhandedness by Downing Street, the PM joked:

“Not everyone’s like Mother Theresa, but there’s not a slavering rottweiler sitting by my desk…”

However, on the point about the “obstacles” to implementing a ban, as shadow environment minister Gavin Shuker wrote on Left Foot Forward last week, this simply doesn’t appear to be the case:

“The Scottish government are pursuing a ban, and animal welfare organisations universally agree with that approach. The RSPCA highlight scientific evidence confirming the incompatibility of wild animals with travelling circuses, whilst Animal Defenders International (ADI) has received advice confirming the legality of a ban.

“So the legal advice received by ADI and the last Labour government validates a ban. The present government was set to proceed likewise before the prime minister intervened. Clearly the legal case cannot be overwhelming, and the government have refused to publish their advice. What are they trying to hide?”

Which all begs the question, why on Earth did David Cameron, and his incompetent environment secretary Caroline Spelman, dig their heels in on this issue? And will they perfom another (this time very welcome) volte-face?

As Simon Carr wrote in this morning’s Indy:

“It was all a disaster for the Tory whips (they’ll get the blame). But will the Government now act on this backbench vote, as promised? It could be a test for Cameron’s grace in defeat.”

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today. 

7 Responses to “Cameron defends circus animals ban farce”

  1. Shaun5446

    Cameron defends circus animals ban farce: http://bit.ly/jFSly9 reports @ShamikDas

  2. Extradition Game

    RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron defends circus animals ban farce: http://bit.ly/jFSly9 reports @ShamikDas #NewsClub

  3. DAVID BUSHELL

    As is well known in the circus industry there is NO SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE that circus animals are in any better or worse conditions than farms zoos safari parks. Imagine my surprise when “left foot forward” published a link to
    this information. The link did not and after 2 weeks still does not work.
    THERE IS NO EVIDENCE
    Dr Marthe Kiley Worthington did an independent scientific report which the RSPCA refused to print because she did not report what they wanted her to. Read “animals in Circuses and zoos” even the RSPCA have published a couple of paragraphs from it !

  4. Pucci Dellanno

    Cameron defends circus animals ban farce: http://bit.ly/jFSly9 reports @ShamikDas

  5. Look Left – Miliband flexes his authority while Cameron U-turns. Again | Left Foot Forward

    […] – despite the best efforts of Number 10, setting up another reverse from the government. Describing the farce, Cameron spoke about having “been through the hoops”, “walked the tightropes” and […]

  6. Bold consensus needed for a better future for Europe’s fisheries | Left Foot Forward

    […] the government to drop the sell-off of England’s forests; and Parliament voted to ban wild animals in […]

  7. Caroline Spelman needs to start doing her job properly | Left Foot Forward

    […] Caroline Spelman associates with a shambles? After the forests sell off failure, the circus animals ban farce and the badger cull catastrophe, comes Spelman’s unwanted meddling in our nation’s […]

Leave a Reply