Several of my Labour-supporting friends have a spring in their step – level in the polls at last, as revealed by yesterday’s Reuters/Ipsos-MORI poll.
![](https://leftfootforward.org/images/2015/02/Labour-rose-199x220.jpg)
Our guest writer is Philip Cowley, Professor of Parliamentary Government at the University of Nottingham, and co-author of The British General Election of 2010, published later this month
Several of my Labour-supporting friends have a spring in their step – level in the polls at last, as revealed by yesterday’s Reuters/Ipsos-MORI poll. How rubbish this new coalition government must be. It took New Labour years to lose its poll lead after 1997.
At the risk of being a party pooper, the trouble is that the experience after 1997 is atypical. After losing in October 1951, Labour had pulled ahead by January 1952, but it didn’t stop the Conservatives enjoying 13 years in government. In 1970, after a June election, Labour were level by October; that didn’t stop Ted Heath polling more votes four years later, even if he didn’t secure enough seats to cling on.
And in 1979, following a May election, Labour had pulled ahead in the polls by the following month. No one needs reminding what that means: Labour led Mrs T’s cutting government within a month of the election and were out of power for the next 18 years.
At this point, one or two of my friends point out that this is an unfair comparison. Those were single party governments, this is a coalition government, we are not comparing like with like, etc etc. All true, and if someone can point me in the direction of polling data from the last British peace-time coalition government formed after a general election, I’ll gladly look at that instead. But you’ll struggle.
What’s happened in the polls is what you’d expect: Government Making Cuts is Unpopular Shocker. Its only significance will come if too many Labour people think it’s significant.
To reach hundreds of thousands of new readers and to make the biggest impact we can in the next general election, we need to grow our donor base substantially.
That's why in 2024, we are seeking to generate 150 additional regular donors to support Left Foot Forward's work.
We still need another 117 people to donate to hit the target. You can help. Donate today.
26 Responses to “Labour’s poll performance is a red herring”
Labour’s poll performance is a red herring « The best Labour blogs
[…] More… […]
Philip Cowley
RT @leftfootfwd: Blogging Prof @PhilipjCowley argues that Labour's poll performance is a red herring http://bit.ly/a3s2fL
Ash
“After losing in October 1951, Labour had pulled ahead by January 1952”
Hang on a minute – Labour were ahead by 48.8% to 48% *on the day of the election*, so there’s no question of them having ‘pulled ahead’ a few months later!
“In 1970, after a June election, Labour were level by October; that didn’t stop Ted Heath polling more votes four years later, even if he didn’t secure enough seats to cling on.”
So after a 3 or 4% bounce immediately after the 1970 election, Labour went on to deprive Heath of his majority in 1974. This time round, Labour’s seen an 8% bounce, and the Tories are *already* without a majority. I can’t say the comparison drains me of all optimism.
“in 1979, following a May election, Labour had pulled ahead in the polls by the following month. No one needs reminding what that means: Labour led Mrs T’s cutting government within a month of the election and were out of power for the next 18 years.”
Sure, but there’s no reason to think we’ll see reversals of fortune on the scale of those caused by the SDP split and the Falklands war this time around.
Obviously we can’t be complacent and can’t rule out ‘events’ getting in the way, but it’s not unreasonable to be encouraged by such a large and rapid recovery in the polls.
Philip Cane
On @leftfootfwd Professor @PhilipjCowley argues that Labour shouldn't get excited about any poll lead http://bit.ly/a3s2fL
DevonChap
Ash, In February 1974 the swing against Labour was 5.9% (from 43.1% in 1970 to 37.2%. While Heath’s Tories lost more its hardly a great triumph and miles away from the 47% Labour were polling 6 months after the 1970 defeat.