On three occasions last night, Gordon Brown asked David Cameron why he was proposing to raise the inheritance tax threshold to £2,000,000 for married couples. On camera, the Tory leader gave an evasive answer. Off camera, he is alleged to have told an audience member, “it’s only a small amount of money”.
During the debate, Cameron said:
“Now, let me answer this question directly about inheritance tax. I believe in this country that if you work hard and you save money and you put aside money and you try and pay down your mortgage on a family home, you shouldn’t have to sell that or give it to the taxman when you die. You should be able to pass it on to your children. It’s the most natural human instinct of all, and I’m afraid these other two parties simply don’t understand that.
“Inheritance tax should only be paid by the richest, by the millionaires; it shouldn’t be by people who’ve worked hard and done the right thing in their lives.”
After the debate, speaking to Keith Bevan – a member of the audience – David Cameron is alleged to have said, “it’s only a small amount of money”. The exchange was relayed by Mr Bevan to listeners of Radio 5 Live:
A Parliamentary Answer from October 2009 says:
“The cost of increasing the inheritance tax threshold to £1 million with effect from April 2010 is estimated at £500 million in 2010-11, £1.2 billion in 2011-12, £1.4 billion in 2012-13 and £1.5 billion in 2013-14. Forecasts beyond 2013-14 have not been made.”
Today’s Guardian fact-checks Gordon Brown’s statement that will, “give an inheritance tax cut to the 3,000 richest people in the country of £200,000”. They conclude:
“Raising the threshold would allow those people to pass on more of their estate tax-free. But it would also benefit around 8,000 families who inherit an estate worth between the current threshold of £325,000 and the £1m mark. Verdict: Correct, but not the whole story”
The £1.2 billion bill for the total of 11,000 estates averages £109,000. The biggest winners could gain £540,000 which is “more than 13 times the cost of the average house in the UK” according to the New Statesman which is more than three times the average house price.
A small amount of money? As Nick Clegg said of Camera’s on camera response, “that’s the most creative justification I’ve ever heard for giving tax breaks to double millionaires.”
I’ve just received a call from the Conservative party press office saying that David Cameron denies making the remarks in the “strongest terms”. As some commenters have pointed out, unlike Rochdale, there’s no recording of the remarks so it’s Mr Bevan’s word against Mr Cameron’s.Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today.