Obsessive focus on poll results is quietly shelved when Labour is ahead
A snap Survation poll for the Mirror newspaper has found that 35 per cent of respondents said Ed Miliband ‘won’ last night’s BBC debate, giving him a clear victory over his rival party leaders.
Who do you think “won” the debate? Survation for @DailyMirror pic.twitter.com/enDDIhTVwu
— Survation. (@Survation) April 16, 2015
But you wouldn’t know it from the coverage this morning in some newspapers, despite their having changed their front pages overnight.
You’ll remember that both the previous ‘debates’ – the Paxman interviews with Miliband and Cameron on March 26 and the seven-way leaders’ debate on April 2 – were reported with heavy emphasis on the polling results about who ‘won’ and who made the best impression on voters.
After the leaders’ debate in April, the Sun newspaper ran a front page story claiming Ed Miliband had blown his election chances by failing to top the polls in the seven-way chatter-fest. The Telegraph ran ‘Miliband flops as outsiders shine’ on its front page, emphasising the poll results, as did the Times, the Guardian and the Independent.
So today’s lack of interest in the polls makes for a rather dramatic contrast.
It’s also worth noting that the poll not only shows Miliband ahead of his fellow debtors, but a general swing in his favour against prime minister David Cameron, (who did not take part in the debate). In a straight contest between Miliband and Cameron, 45 per cent said they would vote for Miliband as prime minister, against 40 percent for Cameron.
Aside for the sins of omission, there are those of commission. An Ipsos Mori poll yesterday taken before the debate which had Labour ahead with 35 per cent was written up in the Evening Standard as ‘Miliband poll blow’.
Focus on these imperfect measurements can be trivial, misleading and a way to avoid discussion of ideas. When it comes to debates, polls are plagued with hazy stupidities (how can one ‘win’ a debate with no formal motion or vote?) and often amount to little more than a measurement of impressions, reducing political argument into a contest between performing seals.
That said, if the media insists on judging debates by poll results, they ought to be consistent. And the only poll on last night’s debate, conducted by a respected polling company, says Miliband smashed it.
Adam Barnett is a staff writer at Left Foot Forward. Follow MediaWatch on Twitter
To reach hundreds of thousands of new readers and to make the biggest impact we can in the next general election, we need to grow our donor base substantially.
That's why in 2024, we are seeking to generate 150 additional regular donors to support Left Foot Forward's work.
We still need another 124 people to donate to hit the target. You can help. Donate today.
19 Responses to “Post-debate polls lead the news agenda – unless Ed Miliband wins”
Gerschwin
Was it performing seals in monkey suits that the Daily Mirror polled or just the usual Labour activists?
Leon Wolfeson
You prove the article correct.
Gerschwin
QED eh? Like I said Leon, you’re a fast learner. Well done.
Leon Wolfeson
And your post content is? Right.
treborc1
Well won what I did not know it was a game show, labour came over as Miliband does he looks at the camera with that stupid look on his face and you look behind you thinking he is looking at somebody.
Farage shot himself in the foot with his left wing audience , as did Miliband then having a go at the SNP leader who shot him down.
Labour 7.5
SNP 8
Plaid 5
Greens 5
Farage 2.