News

Reform’s ‘Doge-style’ crackdown failed to make more savings than other councils, research finds

Reform did not declare savings from scrapping DEI and net zero initiatives either, despite claiming this could save billions

Olivia Barber · 2 mins read

Reform’s Donald Trump-inspired Doge unit has failed to make the huge savings the party promised, new research has found.

As reported by The Guardian,  research by the thinktank Public First Global found that Reform-majority councils failed to cut harder or faster than other local authorities.

This is despite Reform having set up their Department of Government Efficiency (Doge) promising to cut people’s taxes and deliver major savings. 

Earlier this year, Reform’s deputy leader Richard Tice claimed that councils led by his party had identified £700 million in savings in its first year of office.

However, the research by PF Global suggests that the unit has made little tangible difference.

The research looked at the spending intentions of six Reform-majority counties: Derbyshire, Kent, Lancashire, Lincolnshire, Nottinghamshire and Staffordshire, and compared them with several non-Reform-majority counties.

According to the research, of the £254 million stated savings in the latest budgets of the Reform-majority councils, only £30-£44 million represented genuine discretionary cuts, once savings inherited from previous administrations, changes in statutory demand and income generation had been accounted for.

The actual savings represent 12-17% of the £254 million figure and were “much the same proportion as the new discretionary savings we find in comparable non-Reform councils”, the analysis found.

Despite Reform’s repeated pledges to scrap DEI and net zero initiatives in local government to save money, their councils did not declare savings in these areas either, according to PF Global. 

Instead, the majority of the savings came from routine administrative cost-cutting, such as £1.6 million off consultancy fees in Lancashire, rather than major reductions in council spending.

At an event last year, Nigel Farage claimed that diversity, equality and inclusion initiatives alone cost the government £7 billion a year.

Reporting by the Byline Times later revealed that in 2022-23, the civil service spent just £27 million on so-called DEI measures.

Damayanti Chatterjee, a director at PF Global, said the findings showed “Reform-majority councils don’t look very different on spending”, though they had been raising council tax more slowly.

David Taylor, a former Reform councillor and head of the party’s Doge unit in Worcestershire who quit the party over Doge’s failure, said the unit hit “hit choppy waters” owing to legal obstacles, such as GDPR legislation, which prevented the team from accessing sensitive data.

The now independent councillor told The Guardian: “Maybe they thought it was going to be too easy to walk into councils and set this up – that could have been a bit of an oversight at the beginning”. 

Taylor added that he thought “the premise was probably right, but maybe it was just unrealistic”.

Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward

Left Foot Forward doesn't have the backing of big business or billionaires. We rely on the kind and generous support of ordinary people like you.

You can support hard-hitting journalism that holds the right to account, provides a forum for debate among progressives, and covers the stories the rest of the media ignore. Donate today.

Donate today
Scroll to Top