Capitalism is not the solution to climate change

The assertion that the biggest driver of climate change is part of the solution is based on a false premise

Capitalism is ‘part of the solution’ to solving climate change, according to Bank of England governor Mark Carney.

In an interview with Channel 4 News, Mr Carney launched a staunch defence of the economic system, but argued companies needed to manage to risk of climate change or go bankrupt.

The governor of the Bank of England looking at the issue of climate change under the lens of the potential risk to business profits is an entirely predictable development.

There is nothing wrong, on the face of it, with companies aiming to be more sustainable, even if their motivation is often just the PR-friendly concept of ‘corporate social responsibility’.

But industry action as to offset climate breakdown still requires accepting the premise that capitalism is a, if not good, then neutral system in its impact to the environment.

The goal of capitalism is, by definition, constant and frequently unchecked growth, which is fundamentally incompatible with preserving our draining natural resources or offsetting the climate crisis.

Nothing illustrates the impact of unchecked capitalism on our climate than the 2017 report which showed that 100 companies where behind 71% of the world’s fossil fuel emissions.

Any ‘capitalist’, ‘business’ or ‘industry’-led solutions to climate breakdown are motivated by maintaining the current system and protecting profit.

But those actions are wholly inadequate on the fact of the unprecedented existential threat we are now facing.

The 2018 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report sounded the alarm, stressing we only had 12 years to reduce emissions in order to prevent a climate catastrophe.

Some scientists are more pessimistic, arguing that window for action is closer to 18 months.

On the face of such sobering and dread-inspiring numbers, hoping the solution to the problem will comes from those who created it seems about as effective as re-arranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.

The actions demanded by groups such as Extinction Rebellion have been called unrealistic and radical, and they may well be, but nothing short of radical change will give us a fighting chance as a species.

What activists like Extinction Rebellion, Greta Thunberg and the children taking part in school strikes understand is that the time for theoretical and drawn-out discussions around the table is long past.

We need the imagination and will to take the whole table apart and come up with a better solution.

Individual actions to mitigate climate change are admirable and should be encouraged, but nowhere near enough without a radical policy shift on a global scale.

For all the lip service many British politicians pay to climate change, a Committee on Climate Change (CCC) report showed the government is failing to meet its own targets.

Actions like taking on the CCC’s recommendation for the UK to plant 1.5 billion trees to meet the zero emission target can certainly have a tangible impact.

But if we are to tackle this problem in the long term, we need to start striving for an economic system that is not led by growth at the expense of everything else.

Like this article? Left Foot Forward relies on support from readers to sustain our progressive journalism. Can you become a supporter for £5 a month?

7 Responses to “Capitalism is not the solution to climate change”

  1. Chester Draws

    Communism had very low growth. Sadly it also had lots of misery. And was terrible for the environment.

    Venezuela has a terrible environment — basically squalor. It’s system isn’t a solution either.

    If you intend to replace Capitalism, you need a better system. Socialism has so far failed to be better in any respect.

  2. nshgp

    All climate activists get a green stamp in the passports, and the details added to the no fly list.

    New driving license class, electric only, and we change their driving licenses to electric only.
    Cars crashed if caught in any other vehicle.

    No gas fired central heating. We put their names in the public space, and allow a bounty to people who catch them living anywhere that uses gas

    Smart meters, green tariffs and no subsidies. Then when the wind doesn’t blow, we send a message to their smart meter and turn the power off

    Why not? It’s what Greta and ER want. We help them get to their goal, and they are the experimental subjects.

  3. Dave Roberts

    Nobody, apart from a few cranks denies that global warming is happening, what is disagreed upon is how to deal with it. The greens are their own worst enemies because, like the petulant children most seem to be, they stamp their feet and want it now. It’s not going to happen overnight. The industrial revolution took a century and its effects will take time to reverse. Two very good practical responses above I have to say and if this site wants to be taken seriously it needs to listen to those voices.

  4. wg

    My city has embarked on a corporate growth plan based on building houses and increasing its population.

    Apparently, the UK’s population has increased by 178,000 in the last year: comparable, on average, to recent years.

    Extrapolating these figures nationwide it appears that we are replacing our natural environment drastically.

    I’m afraid that we can not do anything about the oncoming destruction.

  5. Tom Sacold

    Capitalism is THE problem.

    Socialism is the answer not luddite greenies and their nutty policies that will simply put ordinary workers out of their jobs and destroy the productive capability required to pay for our society – transport, NHS, education, etc.

  6. Victor Schwanberg

    In a time in which Communist regimes have been rightfully discredited and yet alternatives to neoliberal capitalist societies are unwisely dismissed, I defend the fundamental claim of Marxist theory: there must be countervailing forces that defend people’s needs against the brutality of profit driven capitalism.

  7. Dave Roberts

    Swanberg, smockberg already. Vot do you know about anything? Marxism failed. Get a job and look after your mother.

Leave a Reply