Brexit legal advice: The government is treading on ‘thin ice’ by defying Parliament

Have the Tories just set the ball rolling for a fresh General Election?

The government has been branded a ‘democratic disgrace’, after ignoring a Parliamentary vote demanding the full legal advice on the Brexit deal be released.

Ministers have released a redacted version of the Attorney General’s legal advice on the Irish backstop – despite Parliament voting for the text to be published in full.

Both Labour and Remain campaigners have reacted angrily to the news:

Labour are threatening to call a no-confidence vote in the government – which will pile pressure on the Tories to call a fresh election.

The party could also also call out the government for ‘contempt of Parliament’ is Speaker John Bercow allows it. Last week the Speaker suggested this could be permitted.

The DUP is reportedly considering pulling the plug on its support for the government if a no-confidence votes goes forward. The DUP’s Nigel Dodds has already thrown his party’s weight behind a contempt of Parliament motion should Labour put one forward. 

The refusal is even more insulting as Cabinet members have started to leak the full advice themselves: circumventing Parliament:


One Twitter user suggested the government were actively going against the principle of Parliamentary sovereignty:

Best for Britain spokesperson Layla Moran MP said:

“This is a democratic disgrace – the latest in a series of murky dealings by a backdoor government using increasingly tyrannical methods to push through a bad Brexit deal.

“If the government doesn’t want to publish the legal advice it received over the Irish backstop, it’s because they’re hiding something. What we already know is the government’s top lawyer thinks the deal will leave us trapped under EU regulation with no voice and no veto. It’s pretty much a democratic fire sale.

“This country has a proud history of standing up to tyrants and not letting over zealous politicians steamroll parliamentary democracy. It is now parliament’s job to ensure the government doesn’t get away with keeping the British public in the dark, and selling off our sovereignty.”

The limited legal advice that has been published shows that the UK will be ‘trapped’ in the EU’s customs union, while future governments will be tied to the deal.

The advice states: “The agreement does not contain any provision on its termination. In the absence of such a provision, it is not possible under international law for a party to withdraw from the agreement unilaterally.”

Last week Caroline Lucas MP wrote to the Prime Minister accusing her of ‘misleading Parliament’, after appearing to refute Treasury projections on the economic impact of Brexit. 

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by becoming a Left Foot Forward Supporter today.