Is the Remain vote ‘softer’ than polling suggests?

Signs of an upset in the EU referendum, with voters non-plussed and Labour's campaign 'muted'


The polls are closer than ever and the sense of concern is growing within the campaign to keep the UK in the European Union.

Was this then the week that the campaign got serious, in much the same way as that now infamous poll just a few weeks before the Scottish independence referendum in 2014, which put support for leaving the UK ahead of those wanting to stay in it?

Earlier this week Robert (now Lord) Hayward, who was one of John Major’s polling gurus in 1992, predicted that the country will vote to leave the EU on June 23:

‘Unless something substantial changes in the remaining days of the EU Referendum campaign, the balance of probability is that the nation will vote to Leave.’

His case was simple – the pro-EU vote is far softer than many of the polls have predicted.

Hayward’s views matter because of his uncanny ability to predict things the pollsters miss. In 1992 he successfully picked up on the ‘shy Tory’ vote that sent John Major back to Downing Street.

Last year Hayward again predicted prior to the General Election that the polls were underplaying Conservative support.  Add that to Hayward’s personal view that he wants the UK to stay in the EU and his warning should be taken seriously.

Last night the sense of gloom deepened as Shadow Home Secretary Andy Burnham on BBC Newsnight warned of the very real prospect of the Leave campaign winning the referendum, largely as a result of Labour voters failing to connect with the all too muted campaign Jeremy Corbyn is ‘leading’.

What makes this worse however is that even the pollsters are beginning to cast doubt over their own figures.

Take Scotland as an example, a country where poll after poll has shown a clear lead for those wanting to stay in the EU. For so many it is somewhere seen as certain to vote decisively for Remain.

Yesterday however, IPSOS Mori and IPPR Scotland published the results of focus groups they had run. It found that Scottish voters regard the EU referendum campaign being lower-key and less important than the 2014 independence referendum.

As such, those supporting EU membership in Scotland do not appear to be doing so with much enthusiasm; they seem ready to be persuaded to change their minds by the rest of the campaign; and negativity towards the EU outweighs positivity and is felt with more passion.

Russell Gunson, Director of IPPR Scotland, warned:

‘It seems the EU referendum is more of a ‘tinman’ referendum in Scotland, lacking heart and lacking passion, especially compared to the independence referendum.

While the polls may show significant support for Remain in Scotland, our research shows this support is potentially quite soft, and could therefore weaken between now and the 23rd June.’

In Wales meanwhile, the latest political barometer puts the Leave and Remain campaigns all square at 41 per cent each.

With Welsh Labour AM, Mike Hedges having this week argued that the party in Wales has lost support to UKIP because it had become ‘irrelevant’ to many people’s lives, the sense that the Labour Party is already engaged in a post-mortem is palpable.

Labour needs to up its game, and the Conservative side of the Remain camp needs to step aside and let those on the Left committed to membership make the running over the next two weeks, with a message on jobs, employment, social protection and indeed security.

There needs also to be a targeted consumer offer to the public – talk less about big numbers and the macro issues, and more about bread and butter issues that people really feel, such as the dangers to roaming charge caps being removed if we leave the EU.

Ed Jacobs is a contributing editor at Left Foot Forward

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today.

2 Responses to “Is the Remain vote ‘softer’ than polling suggests?”

  1. Larry Ray

    This analysis is no surprise and Andy Burnham warned a while ago that he could tell when a campaign was failing and this one was. I was initially pleased that Alan Johnson was taking the lead on Labour In but he’s been disappointing. Corbyn seems unable to speak about the EU with any conviction and anyway cannot reach out to people who don’t already agree with him. A core issue for Leave is immigration which has been a persistent dog whistle in British politics as long as I can remember but Labour’s put up a very weak case against Leave on this. They need to tackle his head-on AND point to the benefits to everyone of free movement in the EU. There’s a rumour around (that arises from trying to get a high profile Labour speaker at a local uni debate) that the shadow cabinet have been told to keep a low profile on the issue. I very much hope this isn’t true because this would be unbelievably reckless. There are signs that at the last minute Labour is mounting a more visible campaign. Hope this is not too late.

  2. James Kemp

    Sorry this sort of rubbish from the right wieners gets on my nerves oh we should repeat the same mistakes join the Tories and wonder why like in Scotland were we saved the union and then got a kicking from the people of Scotland in the next polls. Ever thought his message is soft because of the media as usual only reporting the blue side as usual and ignoring our side if it cannot find a lie to suit them.

    Oh and up pops a 4.5%’er who has all the answers trying to say kick out that nasty Corbin vote me in and all your problems will be over. If i and many other people wanted a plastic Tory like Burnham we whould have voted for you. So please put up or shut up!

    Jeremy has been out campaigning virtually every day on sating so how could he have done more? Jonson was put in charge of the IN campaign to stop the mistakes of the past maybe he haven’t done a good job that’s for another day but to say Jeremy hasn’t done enough is a convent lie to suit another addenda only. I have been to one of his meetings and it was amazing and he converted me from a soft out to a solid in so his message is effective and intelligent!

Leave a Reply