So, Mr Cameron, are Tory boys Philip Green and Gary Barlow “morally wrong” as well?

David Cameron is facing charges of hypocrisy over his failure to condemn celeb Tory Gary Barlow's tax avoidance, having last night attacked non-Tory Jimmy Carr.

E-mail-sign-up Donate



David Cameron is feeling the the tax dodging heat today, facing charges of hypocrisy over his failure to condemn celeb Tory Gary Barlow’s tax avoidance, having last night laid into non-Tory Jimmy Carr’s tax arrangements.

Asked by ITN’s Tom Bradby if he thought Barlow’s “tax affairs were morally wrong and should he give back his OBE”, the prime minister passed up the chance to censure his Tory chum, dodging the tax dodging question by saying he would not give a “running commentary on different people’s tax affairs” as “that would not be right”. By which he means ‘I’ll give a commentary on lefty Jimmy Carr, but not my mate Gary Barlow’.

The Tory leader’s lack of consisteny was mocked on Twitter – with people also pointing to Tory tax-dodger-in-chief Sir Philip Green:

Jimmy Carr,Lord Ashcroft,Vodafone,Goldman Sachs,Gary Barlow, I wonder which one doesn’t back tories?” – Jim Macred

“Trying to dismantle the career of Jimmy Carr while not mentioning Gary Barlow speaks volumes about the schoolboy running our country.” – Coffee Punk

“PM now refusing equal criticism of Gary Barlow over tax avoidance after railing against Jimmy Carr. Is it because Barlow is a Tory?” – Sunny Hundal

“Utterly spineless from Cameron. Jimmy Carr is “morally wrong”, but on Tory donor Gary Barlow? No comment. Pathetic.” – Marcus Dysch

“So Cameron has a lot to say about Jimmy Carr but nothing about his mate and Tory boy Gary Barlow. Disgraceful hypocrisy.” – Gavin Callaghan

“pm not willing to do a jimmy carr on gary barlow. think he may regret having done a jimmy carr on jimmy carr actually…” – Joey Jones

“In the Commons Labour question why the PM picked out Jimmy Carr & not “Conservative supporter” Gary Barlow: Watch live” – BBC Politics

“Angela Eagle asking about tax avoidance. Why is Jimmy Carr immoral but Gary Barlow gets an OBE and Philip Green gets a knighthood and a job?” – MD

“You are morally wrong @jimmycarr but Philip Green, Gary Barlow, Lord Ashcroft morally right – they’re Tories. #toffshore” – Dave Cameroon

“Dave quick to kick Jimmy Carr (allegedly a leftie, allegedly a comic) over tax but not Gary Barlow (certainly a Tory, allegedly a singer)” – Kevin Mitchell

“Tory, Gary Barlow, still off the radar for avoiding far, far more tax than Jimmy Carr in an identical scheme. Funny that.” – Paul Lewis

“It’s amazing how Jimmy Carr get his balls chewed off by Prime Minister while Princess Gary Barlow doesn’t even get a mention.” – Coffee Punk

“It appears Cameron has got himself into a right pickle!Hes thought oh lets ‘go for’ lefty Jimmy Carr but then ooops Tory Gary Barlow pops up” – Ian

“Cameron says Jimmy Carr’s tax affairs are “morally wrong” – but he hasn’t had time to look into allegations against Gary Barlow (OBE)” – Polly Curtis

“If Cameron is singling out Jimmy Carr, will he throw same accusation at Gary Barlow? No? Funny that. Could it be that Barlow is a Tory?” – Chris Nicholson

Of course it’s not just Barlow and Green, there’s Ashcroft, Osborne, Mitchell, Hammond…


French leaders attack Cameron’s “red carpet” invite to tax exiles as Carr gets owned 19 Jun 2012

Osborne, Barclays, the Cayman Islands and tax avoidance 17 Apr 2012

Budget 2012: Does Osborne think Caan, Ashcroft and Green are “morally repugnant”? 22 Mar 2012

$3.1 trillion lost to tax evasion globally; cost to Britain: £69.9 billion 25 Nov 2011

Exclusive: 98 of the FTSE 100 companies are addicted to tax havens 11 Oct 2011

Osborne, Mitchell and Hammond accused of tax avoidance 18 Oct 2010

A crackdown on tax dodgers will help the poor and make huge cuts unnecessary 20 Oct 2010

Another week, another Tory tax exile – only this time the Daily Mail sinks him 20 Aug 2010

More pressure on Clegg as we reveal real cost of Green’s £285m tax avoidance 19 Aug 2010

Sign the petition to demand Cameron’s pal Aschroft pays back the £127 million he avoided 2 Mar 2010

Facebook group on Lord Ashcroft’s tax status piles on the pressure 16 Feb 2010

Cameron’s MEPs vote against reforms to clamp down on tax dodgers 11 Feb 2010

Cameron cannot brush aside the Ashcroft tax-status scandal 15 Dec 2009


… Not forgetting Cameron’s “red carpet” invite to greedy French tax dodgers seeking to hop across the Channel to avoid paying their fair share of tax under new French President François Hollande.

Cameron’s Tory party looks like its riddled with tax dodgers, avoiders, evaders – cheats, the real “scroungers” in society, and he seems attracted to them, surrounding himself with these shady characters, “all in it together” with the selfish few, saying not a word against them.

Jimmy Carr has at least, at last, belatedly shown contrition – yet the same cannot be said of any of the Tory tax chisellers. Will Cameron ever condemn them? Don’t hold your breath.


Sign-up to our weekly email • Donate to Left Foot Forward

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

115 Responses to “So, Mr Cameron, are Tory boys Philip Green and Gary Barlow “morally wrong” as well?”

  1. Anonymous

    Look at the Greeks.

    Should the Greeks pay tax and get no services because the money is going on debts?

    Moral question.

    What about the UK? Should we be forced to pay tax and not get all the money going on services?

    What about alternatives? What if there is a cheaper alternative to the state service, should we be forced to pay for the states offering?

    What if we don’t want the service, should we be forced to pay for it?

    In my view, we shouldn’t.

    The only areas where its different is the area where if we don’t take the service, and then end up using it, we rip other people off in the process. For example, if we don’t have insurance for health care in the case of accidents, then end up using emergency treatment, we are ripping other people off.

    Arguing about people’s morals when they are obeying the law, but you don’t like the consequences is wrong. Blame politicians for the mess, because they wrote the law.

    At the end of the day, its going tits up anyway. The UK has tipped and the inevitable result is Greece. Defaults on the contracts have already started.

    20K taken off a median wage earner by changing the state pension system is just a starter.

  2. Garryburns10

    To be fair, Barlow hasn’t made a lot of milage, even recently, out of sticking it to the rich tax dodgers. Carr’s a massive hypocrite for this while the other tax avoiders are just the usual penny pinching rich who have at least tried not to draw attention to it!

  3. Anonymous

    Cheaper for who? Cheaper for the rich, or cheaper for the population? It’s about terminating services for the poor, of course. And of course your slash and burn austerity has made the economy nosedive. THIS IS YOUR PLAN, REJOICE!

    Yes, of course you want to steal pensions from the 99%. You’re a broken record on this.

  4. Anonymous

    Excuses and more excuses.

    It’s clear that you think following HMRC guidance is paying too much tax…

Comments are closed.