“No one uses TfL” Tory: Users should pay, except when they are my voters

Alex Hern digs up some astonishing hypocrisy from the Tory AM who tried to claim that no one uses public transport in London.


Adam Bienkov noted this afternoon the jaw dropping claim by a Tory member of the London Assembly that most Londoners don’t use public transport.

Bienkov reports:

Speaking at a City Hall debate on Boris Johnson’s budget, Tony Arbour claimed that:

It is a fact is it not that relatively few Londoners use London transport in any way. Most people don’t use London transport with any sense of regularity.”

He went on to tell the Mayor that it was a “principal of conservatism” that “those [people] who receive a service are those who should pay for it.

Boris Johnson replied that he would “need to get the figures” Arbour was referring to.

As both Bienkov and Mark Ferguson at LabourList have pointed out, Arbour is hopelessly wrong. With 1.1 billion tube journeys a year, 8.4 million combined daily trips on rail, underground, DLR, bus, tram and taxis, and all methods of transport except car drivers and motorcyclists increasing in the last ten years, it is not a fact that “few Londoners use London transport in any way”.

While his facts need a thorough going over, we at Left Foot Forward are always happy to see politicians staking out their principles, so Arbour’s ‘principle of conservatism’ that ‘those [people] who receive a service are those who should pay for it’, while wrong, could mark him out as a better type of politician.

Except when it comes to his own interests, he’s quite happy to treat principles with the same reckless abandon as facts.

In November 2009, the GLA reported that:

Tony Arbour has welcomed yesterday’s definitive assurance from the Mayor of London that the 24-hour Freedom Pass shall remain.

Commenting after Mayor Questions at City Hall during which Boris Johnson gave an assurance that the Pass would continue, Mr Arbour, the Assembly Member for South West London said:

“Boris delivered his promise for a round the clock Freedom Pass; who can doubt his commitment to keep it?”

And in January 2010, they wrote:

Tony Arbour, Richmond and Kingston’s GLA Member has called on the Royal Parks Agency to concentrate on repairing Richmond Park’s roads rather than attempting to turn its car parks into revenue-raising machines.

Tony said:

“Much of Richmond Park’s perimeter road is in a terrible state. The new aggregate used to resurface the road during the summer has dislodged and is now lying in the road. This has left patches of exposed tar that is being flicked up by passing cars and bikes getting only bodywork, clothes and skin, which is proving very difficult to clean off.

“I call on the Parks agency to deal with this serious problem as a matter of urgency instead of focusing on imposing car parking charges on Park visitors.”

Arbour may have raised the flag of conservative principles in City Hall, but in the end he’s just chasing re-election.

See also:

Fact Check fact checked: London’s fares CAN be cutTom Copley, January 25th 2012

The environment trumps the debate between a tunnel or a bridgeDarren Johnson AM, January 21st 2012

Boris’s electric vehicle boasts are an inverted pyramid of piffleDarren Johnson AM, January 10th 2012

Boris fiddles as London prepares for transport chaosAlex Hern, October 19th 2011

Boris’s backward steps for London on pollution and traffic congestionEleanor Besley, June 3rd 2011

As you’re here, we have something to ask you. What we do here to deliver real news is more important than ever. But there’s a problem: we need readers like you to chip in to help us survive. We deliver progressive, independent media, that challenges the right’s hateful rhetoric. Together we can find the stories that get lost.

We’re not bankrolled by billionaire donors, but rely on readers chipping in whatever they can afford to protect our independence. What we do isn’t free, and we run on a shoestring. Can you help by chipping in as little as £1 a week to help us survive? Whatever you can donate, we’re so grateful - and we will ensure your money goes as far as possible to deliver hard-hitting news.

9 Responses to ““No one uses TfL” Tory: Users should pay, except when they are my voters”

  1. Alex Hern

    @BorisWatch Tony Arbour also doesn't quite live up to the "user should pay" principle he was espousing, either: http://t.co/irE8j4QK

  2. leftlinks

    Left Foot Forward – “No one uses TfL” Tory: Users should pay, except when they are my voters http://t.co/aYs8REYc

  3. Adam Bienkov

    "No one uses TfL" Tory in 2009: "Freedom Passes are great!" 2012: "If you ride, you pay": http://t.co/1EbP40J4 by @alexhern

  4. Pulp Ark

    “No one uses TfL” Tory: Users should pay, except when… http://t.co/KDLy1NUS #Public_Services_for_All #Boris_Johnson #muslim #tcot #sioa

  5. Political Planet

    “No one uses TfL” Tory: Users should pay, except when they are my voters: Alex Hern digs up some astonishing hyp… http://t.co/lAZoHIrS

  6. Anonymous

    140 million on 5,000 bicycles = 28,000 pounds a bike.

    Just like Ken and his mad cap schemes, Boris is equally bonkers.

  7. Blarg1987

    Be intersting to note privatisation usually starts with people pay for it themselves, then it is “too expensive” so then sold off, then subsidies have to be provided to make it viable which cost more then the origional system (rail networks subsidies 5 times pre privatisation), sorry to be cynical but I can only go on what history has shown 🙂

  8. Mr. Sensible

    Well that will go down well with voters facing above inflation increases won’t it… See what Cameron makes of it given he’s supposed to be leading the greenest government ever…

  9. Throwing money at the strike problem: Can the Tube be automated? | Left Foot Forward

    […] “No one uses TfL” Tory: Users should pay, except when they are my voters – Alex Hern, February 9th […]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.