Different perspectives on Gaza: Arab commentators and Labour MPs

Big gaps have opened up between the political analyses and proscriptions being proposed by Labour Party MPs and by many Arab commentators.

Gaza rocket ncrj

Big gaps have opened up between the political analyses and proscriptions being proposed by Labour Party MPs and by many Arab commentators

While the humanitarian concern for civilian causalities is universally shared, and ceasefire efforts must be supported, yesterday’s debate on Gaza in the House of Commons showed that big gaps have opened up between the political analyses and proscriptions being proposed by Labour Party MPs and by many Arab commentators. The gaps should give the party cause to pause.

Who is responsible for the conflict in Gaza?

‘The current crisis and the carnage in Gaza is caused essentially by the failure of Israel ever to recognise the rights, needs or justice of the Palestinian people.’ ( Jeremy Corbyn MP, Islington North, Lab.)

‘Hamas deliberately created the crisis in Gaza.’ (Egyptian Broadcaster Amani al-Hayat, reported in Ynet)

‘Hamas continues to trade in the blood of the innocent people in Gaza and it has rejected calls for a cease-fire.’ (Ahmed Al-Jarallah, Arab Times – Kuwait.)

Who is responsible for the lack of a cease fire?

Almost all Labour MPs: ‘Israel’ (even after being told by an incredulous Prime Minister countless times that Israel had accepted, but Hamas had rejected the Egyptian proposed cease-fire.)

In Kuwait’s Arab Times, Editor-in-Chief Ahmad Al-Jarallah criticised Hamas’s rejection of a ceasefire and wrote that, ‘it is up to the Palestinians to get rid of their illusions and sincerely try to contemplate the benefits brought forth by Egypt’s initiative.’

Should we hold Hamas to account?

‘The PM rightly spoke of his anger at the deaths in Ukraine and the dangers of turning a blind eye when big countries bully smaller countries. Will he apply those maxims to Gaza? Will he stop blaming the Palestinians for the murder of their own children?’ (Andy Slaughter MP, Hammersmith, Lab.)

‘Hamas is playing … a PR game at the expense of the people who are living in Gaza. Where are the journalists [that need to] tell Hamas and [Islamic] Jihad to stop? Do you find it normal that terrorists hide under civilian houses and by [doing] that hurt the same people that they are trying to protect? Do you think that this is something that is normal, that these terrorists are actually making the Palestinian people lose their lives?’ Lucy Aharish, i24news, the first Arab mainstream news anchor while working for Channel 10 in 2007.

Ahmed Qandeel, head of the Energy Studies Program at the Al-Ahram Strategic Studies think-tank, denounced the targeting of Israel’s nuclear facility in Dimona as ‘idiotic’ and warned this endangers the lives of Egyptians and Arabs: ‘Egypt must take precautionary measures.’

‘The Egyptian people are asking: Where are our people who were kidnapped and taken to the Gaza Strip? Hamas should apologize for the 1,000 tunnels that were used to smuggle the resources of Egypt. They all have their own planes and accounts in Swiss banks.’ (Mustafa Shardi, journalist.)

What is the balance of responsibility for civilian deaths?

‘What will [the Prime Minister] do today, tomorrow and through the week in the Security Council to stop the slaughter of the innocents in Gaza.’ (Liam Byrne MP, Birmingham, Hodge Hill, Lab.)

‘Everybody here hates Hamas. But they’re too afraid to say so publicly. Our food comes from Israel but what we give them in return is rockets.’ (Abu Ali who identified himself only by his first names to avoid Hamas retribution, a driver for his family business in Gaza, told the Associated Press.)

‘Can the Prime Minister seriously tell the House that, had he been in power at the time of republican bombings in the United Kingdom, he would have sanctioned the use of carpet bombing, close range artillery and naval bombardment in parts of Belfast and Kilburn?’ (Grahame M. Morris MP, Easington, Lab.)

‘Hamas is more isolated than ever. The organization is revolting against the legitimate Palestinian leadership, while it is perceived globally as a criminal organization raining rockets down onto Israel.’ (Saudi Arabian newspaper Al Watan.)

‘Given that the Prime Minister said in his statement today that the indiscriminate targeting of men, women and children is a war crime, why does he not condemn Israeli actions, rather than just making excuses for them, as he has done today?’ (Mark Hendrick MP, Preston, Lab/Co-op.)

‘Such idiotic decision-making [by Hamas] … forces the Gaza Strip and its people, as well as the entire Arab Nation in its entirety, to pay a very steep price in fragmentation, in humiliation, in martyrs and, unfortunately, in blood – shed in vein, with no prospects for victory.’ (Khaled Salah, Al-Nahar TV, July 9, 2014.)

‘For the avoidance of doubt, will the Prime Minister agree that the targeting of civilians or wilful disregard for the lives of civilians is a crime, whether those civilians are flying in a civilian aircraft, sheltering in their homes in south Israel or sheltering in their homes in Gaza?’ (Richard Burden MP, Birmingham, Northfield, Lab.)

‘Why [was] Hamas successful in spreading a sophisticated network of tunnels and fail to build simple bomb shelters …? Is Hamas willing to sacrifice Palestinians to get more Arab and foreign financial aid … Hamas leaders are jet setters.’ (Abdulateef Al-Mulhim of arabnews.com)

‘What is the Government’s assessment of the reports that the Israelis are using illegal white phosphorus as part of their illegal campaign in Gaza?’ (There have been no such reports.) (Khalid Mahmood MP, Birmingham, Perry Barr, Lab.)

Should Israel negotiate with an unreformed Hamas that seeks its destruction?

‘Israel [should] negotiate with Hamas.’ (Peter Hain MP, Neath, Lab.)

‘The vast majority of the countries participating in [the Arab League] summit consider Hamas to be a terrorist organization. These countries pray – all those foreign ministers are praying – that Israel will manage to get rid of Hamas once and for all.’ (Arab journalist, Abd Al-Bari Atwan.)

Saudi newspaper Al Watan: ‘Hamas’s isolation, its diplomatic impotence, its disconnection from the [Palestinian] Authority and rebellion against anyone who is a legitimate representative of the Palestinian people makes it appear as a criminal in the eyes of the rest of the world.’

‘We are not prepared to sacrifice even a single hair from the eyebrow of an Egyptian soldier or civilian, for the sake of Hamas … They goad people into fighting, terrorism, and violence, under the pretext of “Jihad,” while they themselves sit at a hotel, a swimming pool, or a nudist beach, eating a variety of dishes, marrying four wives, and driving the latest model luxury cars.’ Maher Shahin said (Al-Tahrir TV, July 12, 2014):

‘Thank you Netanyahu and may God give us more [people] like you to destroy Hamas!’ (Azza Sami of the Egyptian newspaper Al-Ahram.)

What is needed now to bring peace?

‘There will not be peace and security until such time as Israel recognises the right of the Palestinians to live in security as well and agrees to a two-state solution.’ (Jack Dromey MP, Birmingham, Erdington, Lab.)

‘May I simply ask the Prime Minister what pressure he is prepared to apply, if he will not pursue economic sanctions against Israel?’ (Lyn Brown MP, West Ham, Lab.)

‘Most Arabs are busy these days with bloody battles waged by their leaders, who are struggling to survive. These battles are raging in Yemen, Syria, Iraq, Egypt, Libya and the Palestinian Authority.’ (Mohammed al-Musafer, columnist.)

‘When is Britain going to bring pressure to bear to get the Israelis to comply with international law, to end the blockade of Gaza and the settlements on the west bank?’ (Frank Dobson, Holborn and St Pancras, Lab.)

Hamas ‘don’t understand that peace, too, is something you must struggle for with all your might … Therefore it is necessary to persist with efforts to impose peace. No other option exists. True resistance is resistance to illusions and false hopes, and no longer leaning on the past in building the future.’ (Abdallah Hamid Al-Din the Saudi writer and intellectual in London based paper Al-Hayat on 12 July.)

A simplistic ‘Blame Israel’ approach will not do for Labour. The left-wing Haaretz newspaper called Hamas the Islamists – who have fired 15,200 rockets and mortars, an average of over three rocket attacks every single day, have targeted Israel since 2001 – a ‘cruel, fanatic, fundamentalist, reactionary, totalitarian, misogynistic, Holocaust denying, human rights-abusing, anti-democratic, anti-American, anti-Western, anti-Christian, anti-Zionist and anti-Semitic movement that embraces terror, sanctifies martyrdom, glorifies death and condemned the killing of Osama bin Laden.’

These Commons statements are the kind of knee jerk response one might expect in a student union debate – trite soundbites that show no grasp of the horrific choices facing Israel, the reality of who Hamas are and what motivates them, and ignorance of how the conflict is being conducted, how the IDF operates compared to other armies including our own, or how on earth one might try to deal with vicious terrorists operating embedded in a civilian population in an urban area.

I don’t expect Labour MPs to cheerlead for Israel or to be glib about civilian casualties but I do expect them to study what is actually going on and deliver balanced, insightful and constructive comments rather than speak as though they are regurgitating the round robin emails the PSC has been flooding their in-box with.

Alan Johnson is the editor of Fathom – For a deeper understanding of Israel and the region

15 Responses to “Different perspectives on Gaza: Arab commentators and Labour MPs”

  1. Anthony

    A very interesting contrast though of course not every Arab commentator would agree with the quotes picked out here.

    The real question that must be asked of Labour MPs, and others protesting Israel’s actions, is what exactly they believe Israel should be doing instead in the short term. We all know that in the medium to long term Israel must push forward a true and lasting peace and end its occupation. But in the short term how do Labour MPs and others think Israel should respond to Hamas rocket attacks?

    If they cannot state clearly and cogently what precisely they think it is acceptable for Israel to do then their condemnations are not at all helpful. They surely do not expect Israel to do nothing at all to stop the rocket attacks on its civilians? So we must demand that if they condemn what Israel is doing they must also tell us what Israel ought to be doing.

  2. Dave Roberts

    I was unaware that Gaza was occupied by Israel, did I miss something? I was under the impression that Israel evicted all the settlers there , dismantled their houses and pulled out in return for peace. Was I wrong about this?

  3. Anthony

    This is a distraction from my point but just to set the record straight. The West Bank is occupied and it is not sensible to try and completely divorce the situation in Gaza from that. However, as I stated, that is a medium to long term issue. The focus now must be on the short term issue which is Hamas firing rockets from Gaza at Israel. Those who condemn Israel’s actions to stop that must also tell us what actions they would find acceptable.

  4. mightymark

    Yes, some deeply troubling comments from some Labour MPs here though in fairness many of those quoted are are just the “usual suspects”. More troubling however was Ed Miliband’s condemnation of the Israeli ground invasion. I am none too clear whether this is because he is simply against it on principle or whether he is substituting his judgment for that of Israel’s leaders who judge it necessary to their defence. Either way it marks a departure from the line Tony Blair took some years back as PM in a similar crisis where he did appreciate the need for Israel to have time to complete military operations to defend itself .

    By coincidence my Labour Party membership fell due for renewal this week and as a result of all this I confess my fingers twitched a little over the “cancel direct debit” option in my on line bank account. In the end I let it go ahead thinking of the number of pro Israeli people I have myself urged to stay their own twitching fingers over anti Israeli sentiment in the party. There may however come a point when I and they will become less tolerant of those in the party who are prepared to risk or play politics with the future of the world’s only Jewish state

  5. Oren Paynton

    All these misguided Labour MPs would be correct in their analysis only had the conflict existed in the calm, settled and civilized British environment. Alas, Israel is required to survive under a very different set of rules. If all these MPs, just for one day, had to make the moral and existential judgments that their Israeli counterparts regularly make, I think their view on the world might just change a little.
    It is very easy to sit in the comfort of the Westminster bar passing criticism over people thousands of miles away who need to make tough decisions just in order to survive.
    I would recommend some of these MPs take a trip over to Israel to see what it actually is like, only most world airlines have now decided it is too dangerous to land there…

  6. Karen

    I think you will find if you scrutinise the legal facts that the West Bank is not occupied territory. The 67 borders have never been legal borders but merely the green line marking the division of troupes when fighting stopped. In actual fact the only time the West Bank has been occupied is for the years between 1946 and 1966 when Jordan occupied. The West Bank is bone-fide land given to the Jewish peoples as a Jewish Homeland by the League of Nations and ratified in the San Remo Agreement .

  7. Gary Scott

    Oh well, glad that’s all cleared up then. Israel ARE justified in killing all those civilians.

  8. Steve

    Funny you don’t quote Gerald Kaufman. I think he knows what he’s talking about. Watch his brilliant speech in the debate.

  9. rdtgfedagdsgf

    I really don’t understand why you are publishing this. It is absolutely preposterous that this man, who is literally a paid propagandist for the actions of Israel, is accusing others of trading in ‘propaganda rather than constructive comments’. For instance:

    ” Israel had accepted, but Hamas had rejected the Egyptian proposed cease-fire.”

    Well yes – because Hamas weren’t closely involved in negotiating it, it was agreed between two of their main enemies – precisely so they could say ‘look, Hamas don’t want peace’. Why the hell should they agree to it? Would Israel agree to a ceasefire deal that had been written by Hamas and Iran? That’s the exact equivalent. But Alan Johnson thinksthis somehow demonstrates they are to blame for everything.

    Al;an Johnson (am guessing he’s had to forsake the ‘Professor’?) accuses others of using ‘trite soundbites’ but that’s all his piece is – a succession of pro-Israel soundbites. It’s his job to produce them, but it doesn’t mean blogs have to host them.

    I’d like to see Alan Johnson’s response to Israel blowing up a school, with the IDF having been asked repeatedly to allow its evacuation today (and having not even answered). I’m guessing he’d blame it on left-wingers, or some such bollocks. Shameful.

  10. Leon Wolfeson

    It’s no real surprise if you look at Ed’s advisers…there are a couple of fairly nasty characters there.

  11. Guest

    Yes, as you uncritically and unthinking support Hamas you wouldn’t.

  12. Eilidh Darling

    Hasbara. – Nothing to see here. –

  13. Guest

    Yea, you should keep your hash bar habbit to yourself.

  14. Guest

    What a surprise, you oppose killing Hamas’s fighters, who are civilians.

  15. Eilidh Darling

    @Leon Wolfson
    “Yea, you should keep your hash bar habbit to yourself.”

    Even you can do better than that. (Though… on second thought, maybe you can’t.)

    https://wikispooks.com/w/images/e/e7/Hasbara_Handbook.pdf
    (My nephew brought back a copy from college. He’s not even Jewish. -LOL-)

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_diplomacy_(Israel)

    http://www.richardsilverstein.com/2009/07/10/the-israel-projects-secret-hasbara-handbook-exposed/

    http://mondoweiss.net/2014/06/hasbara-household-word.html

Leave a Reply