Charities and unions voice ‘deep concern’ about Milburn review’s recommendation to cut young people’s benefits
"Moving now to cut payments for under-25s will not fix their issues or provide them with a better future"
Trade unions and disability charities have raised concerns about the disability benefit cut recommendations made in Alan Milburn’s youth unemployment review.
The 278-page report published today has included youth benefit cuts as a key recommendation for tackling the growing crisis of young people who are not in education, employment or training (Neet).
According to official figures, an estimated 981,000 of 16- to 24-year-olds in the UK are Neet, accounting for 13% of that age group. Milburn’s report says the government should get that figure down to 5% by 2036.
One of Milburn’s key recommendations is for the government to scrap the health element of Universal Credit and the disability benefit, Personal Independence Payment (PIP), for under 25s.
In his report, Milburn argues that the reforms to Universal Credit and PIP are necessary to reduce the benefits bill and prevent more young people from getting “trapped in economic activity”.
He says they would save £3.6 billion per year by 2036.
Milburn proposes replacing the health element of UC for under 25s with a Youth Allowance, which would pay the same amount as the standard rate of UC.
PIP would be replaced with a new “additional costs allowance”, which would help cover extra costs relating to a condition but is likely to be available to fewer claimants than PIP is.
Milburn, who served as health secretary under Tony Blair and has worked as a consultant to several private healthcare firms since leaving Parliament, is facing criticism for his benefit-cutting proposals.
Disability charity Scope has welcomed Milburn’s proposal to improve employment support for young people, but criticised his benefit cut recommendations.
James Taylor, executive director of strategy at Scope, said: “We welcome Alan Milburn’s ambition to transform employment support for young people. Too many young disabled people are being shut out of work, so more personalised help to find and stay in jobs, and action to get employers hiring young disabled people, could transform a generation’s prospects.
“But we are deeply concerned by proposals that could leave some young disabled people with less financial support. PIP helps with the extra costs of disability, whether someone is in work or not. Taking that support away could make it harder, not easier, for young disabled people to get into work and live independently.”
George Bangham, head of social policy at the New Economics Foundation, said: “There’s much to welcome in Alan Milburn’s review, including calls for more investment in employment support and a guarantee of a job, training or support for every young person. But the positives risk being overshadowed by his argument for cuts to health and disability benefits.
“There is little evidence that health benefits are too generous or that they are driving young people out of work, while cutting them is likely to push people into poverty and make it harder for them to find work.”
Citing recent NEF research which found that, in Blackpool, there are only five online vacancies for every 100 people out of work, Bangham said: “Cuts to benefits also don’t solve the fundamental problem that there aren’t enough opportunities for young people.”
Fran Heathcote, the general secretary of PCS union, said: “The mental health crisis among our young people is not the fault of public services but is a result of decades of under-funding by successive governments.
“Moving now to cut payments for under-25s will not fix their issues or provide them with a better future, they will need both financial and specialised work-coach support to help bring them into the working environment.”
Heathcote added: “PCS is absolutely opposed to any tightening of sanctions, and the cutting of benefits which will only push claimants further away from the labour market and deeper into poverty, potentially creating an even worse crisis”.
UNISON general secretary Andrea Egan said: “The prime minister is right to say young people should be prioritised for investment rather than targeted for cuts. That means he must reject proposals to slash disability support for under-25s.
Egan added: “However they’re rebranded, these are still welfare cuts. Ministers may no longer be demonising claimants but that’s cold comfort to the young people singled out in this review.
“Many of them are neurodivergent or living with mental health conditions. What they need most is support and treatment.”
Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward
Left Foot Forward doesn't have the backing of big business or billionaires. We rely on the kind and generous support of ordinary people like you.
You can support hard-hitting journalism that holds the right to account, provides a forum for debate among progressives, and covers the stories the rest of the media ignore. Donate today.
Donate today