The Japanese don't really eat much lamb.
As Boris Johnson visits Wales today, his Secretary of State for Wales Alun Cairns was getting a grilling on the Today Show.
Cairns was given the difficult job of arguing that a no-deal Brexit – in which 40% tariffs will be applied to UK lamb exports to the European Union – won’t devastate the Welsh lamb industry.
It’s a difficult job partly because Cairns probably doesn’t believe it himself. As Nick Robinson pointed out, while campaigning for Remain in 2016, he said: “Farming, one of our major industries, is a huge winner from Wales being in Europe.”
After the referendum though, he converted to Leave, earning a promotion and surviving Johnson’s cabinet reshuffle by defending no-deal Brexit.
According to The Farmers Union of Wales though, a no-deal Brexit would lead to “civil unrest”.
Nick Robinson asked what Cairns would say to them and their members?
First, he said, the government is trying to reach a deal with the European Union. Good luck with that.
Second, he said: “I would point to the market in Japan that has just been opened to Welsh and British sheep…that is a significant market for which we haven’t even scratched the surface.”
This market has been opened because the UK is a member of the EU. When we leave, the market will be closed.
As the government’s own website admits, the Japan free trade deal will not be transitioned for exit day.
Also, Japan is not a significant market in terms of lamb. Japan has a quarter of the EU’s population and they eat a lot less lamb than the average European.
According to the OECD, the average European Union citizen eats 1.8kg of lamb a year. The average Japanese person eats just 0.1kg.
Of course, the Japanese could start eating more lamb, and import it from Wales – just as the Welsh could develop a taste for Japanese products like eel – but it’s unlikely.
Analysis by Hybu Cig Cymru suggests 92.5% of lamb export rade could dissapear in a no-deal. As the Farmers Union of Wales say, this would be “disastrous”.
To reach hundreds of thousands of new readers and to make the biggest impact we can in the next general election, we need to grow our donor base substantially.
That's why in 2024, we are seeking to generate 150 additional regular donors to support Left Foot Forward's work.
We still need another 124 people to donate to hit the target. You can help. Donate today.
4 Responses to “Japan won’t rescue Welsh lamb industry from no-deal”
Tom Sacold
The real scandal of lamb production in the UK is the fact that over 50% is produced through cruel non-stun ritual slaughter.
Cole
A shame the Welsh backed Brexit – including, apparently, quite a few farmers.
GW
I lived in Japan for 3 years about 15 years ago. I never saw lamb as an option in a Japanese restaurant, not once, its simply not part of their diet. And as 98% of people in Japan are Japanese (as opposed to migrants), then if you don’t sell to them the market is pretty small. I don’t know if Alun Cairns is being deliberately mendacious or is just ignorant, but it needs stating that the Japanese market for lamb will in no way be a substitute for loss of lamb exports to the EU.
John Dakers
Most Japanese – in my experience living in Tokyo – ‘can’t stand’ the smell of lamb – you couldn’t give it away – much less develop an export strategy – there would be better odds on the Martians landing armed
with a vat of mint sauce