Comments on: Lib Dems are winning seats Labour held since 1935. Has the ‘revival’ begun?   https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/ Left Foot Forward is the home for UK progressives. We provide evidence-based analysis on British politics, news and policy. Tue, 27 Sep 2016 02:38:08 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.5 By: David Davies https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/comment-page-3/#comment-831663 Tue, 27 Sep 2016 02:38:08 +0000 https://leftfootforward.org/?p=115172#comment-831663 If we turf out the Blue Labour tories out of Real Labour, the re-establishment of a cogent opposition will emerge under JC. No one will ever believe the LibDoom again, after Clodd reneged upon everything that he believed in to get what he thought was power.

]]>
By: Boffy https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/comment-page-3/#comment-831175 Sun, 25 Sep 2016 07:26:15 +0000 https://leftfootforward.org/?p=115172#comment-831175 “This rebellion wasn’t caused by racism or a paroxysm of infantile anger. It was considered. The workers spied an opportunity to take the elite that despises them down a peg or two — and they seized it.”

Really? In that case it was the biggest exercise in cutting your nose off to spite your face in a very long time, as they put in place an even more right-wing, even more anti-working class section of the Tory Party than were in office before!

Moreover, those “ordinary” voters (whoever they may be) you refer to, had the opportunity to the vote for the Lib-Dems as an alternative to Labour in 2015, but instead the Liberals got annihilated. They had the opportunity to vote for them in 2016, after Corbyn became Labour Leader, but in the London Assembly elections they came fifth!

The Liberals and the Labour Right keep talking about this mythical centre ground, and keep telling us that elections can only be won upon it, but in every election over the last few years, it has been shown to be a fantastical construction in the heads of career politicians and journalists who live in the same establishment bubble. If they really believe what they say they would have already gone ahead with a repetition of the SDP/Liberal lash up of the 1980’s, but they won’t because they know its a fantasy.

It had a better chance of success in the 1980’s, because of the specific conditions, but look at the actual support for parties during that period, and you will see that Labour continued to have the largest support, up until the Falklands War. All the SDP did was to take enough support away from Labour to prevent it winning, and thereby as the Liberals and SNP had done in 1979, it acted as support for the right-wing Thatcherites, just as Clegg acted as support for Cameron.

But, having fulfilled that role the SDP/Liberal lash-up in the 1980’s disappeared, having put Thatcher in office, and Clegg’s Liberals have disappeared having put Cameron in office, and thereby making way for May, Johnson, Davis and all the other reactionary throwbacks.

]]>
By: Derek Emery https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/comment-page-3/#comment-830981 Sat, 24 Sep 2016 10:39:11 +0000 https://leftfootforward.org/?p=115172#comment-830981 Labour have moved hard left into the long grass to minimise their attraction to ordinary voters. Some ordinary voters will turn to the Lib Dems – the next party right along the political spectrum.
Lib Dem politics are not right enough for most. They do not map into the wants and needs of the many in social group C, D and E who are conservative with a small c, and are against mass immigration and internationalism because they have been the biggest losers for decades. See Brexit voters are not thick, not racist: just poor http://www.spectator.co.uk/2016/07/brexit-voters-are-not-thick-not-racist-just-poor/
…This rebellion wasn’t caused by racism or a paroxysm of infantile anger. It was considered. The workers spied an opportunity to take the elite that despises them down a peg or two — and they seized it. They asserted their power, and in the process, blimey: they changed the world…

]]>
By: Carol Angharad https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/comment-page-2/#comment-830754 Fri, 23 Sep 2016 15:22:56 +0000 https://leftfootforward.org/?p=115172#comment-830754 Someone from my CLP went to work in the Tupton by-election (NE Derbys) I was told that very few of the 33Labour Councillors on the District Council came & canvassed or did anything for the candidate, very little on the ward was canvassed & and only one area was knocked up on the day because there were so few volunteers. This person, who is not an avid JC supporter said no one mentioned JC to him on the doorstep. The day when areas who could weigh the Labour vote without doing anything are over. I would suggest this seat was lost because the ward organisation did not exist & no one has been interested in reaching out to voters. The voters are interested in politics & want to hear from us, if you live in marginal council seats you know this, you can also win Tory seats with a lot of effort. The Tories maybe going home to the LibDems but we can win, & won 4 council seats last night.

]]>
By: Boffy https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/comment-page-2/#comment-830673 Fri, 23 Sep 2016 09:17:17 +0000 https://leftfootforward.org/?p=115172#comment-830673 I never thought you were referring to Labour MP’s. There are plenty of Labour Party members who have thought they had a direct route to becoming a career Councillor, and from there to some other sinecure.

I’d already replied to the “other points” in response to others comments. Winning Council seats in specific areas, and in by-elections, on low polls means nothing. A gain of 14 net Council seats is hardly anything to write hom about when you have just seen your MP’s reduced from 70 to 8!

As for your free market ideology, haven’t you read the Liberals history as a party, have you not read your “Orange Book”. David Laws was a more enthusiastic free marketer than George Osbourne, and after he was gone he was replaced by the equally pro-market Alexander. You’ve got away with your two-faced position in the past at local level, but having gone into government as soon as your MP’s smelled Ministerial leather, your true nature has been exposed, and rejected by the voters, which is why a lash up with you, or a return to your kind of politics by the Blair-rights, and their fetish of the “centre-ground” is a non-started.

Its a bit rich for any Liberal to criticise Labour members for the Tories getting into office. You had the perfect opportunity to prevent that in 2010, but instead found a natural home in government with the most right-wing Tory government for decades. Now Your ex Leader Clegg wants you to lash up another coalition with them, which he had hoped to achieve at the last General Election!

]]>
By: Rebecca Taylor https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/comment-page-2/#comment-830500 Thu, 22 Sep 2016 15:59:52 +0000 https://leftfootforward.org/?p=115172#comment-830500 @Boffy – I wasn’t referring to Labour MPs, but Labour party members, sorry if that wasn’t clear. And I don’t think Ed Balls would be welcome in the Liberal Democrats; he’s far too illiberal! Funnily enough I was the LibDem candidate in Morley in 2015 and with no money and no time (my full time non political day job was really busy), I got 1400 votes while Mr Balls lost his seat by 400, so I would like to claim a modicum of credit.

I notice you have not commented on the other points I made, but have reverted to tribalistic “the LibDem are dead” rhetoric. At the last general election, many parts of the Labour party were so dedicated to kicking the LibDems that they forgot to kick the Tories, which helped them beat Labour and win an unexpected majority. The Tories are still thanking you now!

Not sure where you get the idea that LibDems are free market obsessives from. You write as if we’re like those right wing libertarians who want to marketise everything and regulate nothing. Ironically, we LibDems get accused by right wingers of being “anti-business” due to wanting to do things such as crack down on tax avoidance and better regulate markets.

]]>
By: Boffy https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/comment-page-2/#comment-830482 Thu, 22 Sep 2016 14:55:37 +0000 https://leftfootforward.org/?p=115172#comment-830482 “Depending on how accurate you think social media is, there has certainly been noise in recent days from some Labour members along the lines of “if Corbyn is re-elected I’m joining the LibDems”. ”

Which tells you exactly where the Lib Dem corpse is lying. Its seen as a free market outfit, that might provide a home for right-wing Labour careerists, with similar free market ideas, and hope to get themselves some sinecure at a local level, or maybe even an appointment to the House of Lords that well known bastion of democratic principles where so many Liberals are already massively over represented.

The fact that people like Ed Balls will not touch the Liberals with a barge pole shows that the PLP rebels know that route is a dead end. It would be literally sadistic, necrophiliac, bestiality, i.e. beating a dead horse.

]]>
By: Rebecca Taylor https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/comment-page-2/#comment-830477 Thu, 22 Sep 2016 14:35:30 +0000 https://leftfootforward.org/?p=115172#comment-830477 There are a few things Boffy appears not to have noticed including:

* Surge in LibDem membership (now around 80,000 – higher than when Charles Kennedy was leader) since the referendum.

* The LibDems have not only won several solid Labour seats in council by-elections recently, but have also won seats from the Tories and UKIP too. The seats are in very different parts of the country including Sheffield, Derbyshire, Cornwall, East Sussex and Cardiff. This means the LibDems currently have the best council by-election record of any party since May 2016 (15 gains, no losses, 100% defence rate).

* The LibDems also had the best English council election results of any party in May. We had an overall gain of 45 seats and gained control of 1 council. This compares to overall losses of 48 for the Tories and overall losses of 18 for Labour at a time when the main opposition party should be winning, especially as I believe the seats up for election in May this year tended to be in Labour strongholds.

*In Scotland we retained the same number of MSPs (Labour lost 13 seats) and took two constituency seats from the SNP. (We had awful Welsh Assembly results with the exception of the brilliant Kirsty Williams, but the Welsh by-election gain from Labour this week shows that can change).

This is only a modest start in our party’s fightback, but a serious start it is.

Depending on how accurate you think social media is, there has certainly been noise in recent days from some Labour members along the lines of “if Corbyn is re-elected I’m joining the LibDems”. A few have already jumped ship, but I think they make up a small proportion of LibDem newbies, most of whom have never joined a political party before. Interesting times….

]]>
By: Tony https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/#comment-830454 Thu, 22 Sep 2016 12:33:59 +0000 https://leftfootforward.org/?p=115172#comment-830454 One big problem they have is that they rarely appear in the broadcast media. Question Time and Any Questions etc. rarely have them on since the general election disaster. The conference season is an exception.

]]>
By: (Peter StJohn Howe ) 'SINJUN' https://leftfootforward.org/2016/09/lib-dems-are-winning-seats-labour-held-since-1935-has-the-revival-begun/#comment-830404 Thu, 22 Sep 2016 08:27:16 +0000 https://leftfootforward.org/?p=115172#comment-830404 Wrong Wrong. The Analysis is based on preconceived leanings.

On a National level the Libdems have messed it up big time.
Consider the following :
*The predictions that were made and are being made by Clegg are 180 degrees out on The Economy and EU stability and effectiveness .
*Clegg was wrong but his self confidence and Ego made him a big personality which Farron totally lacks ,
*Any party needs a big character as a leader to whom voters can relate . The lib Dems have not got one.
*The Lib Dems are peddling lines appropriate to the 1970s or before . The voters have moved on.
The middle to left ground has been hoovered up by Theresa Mays reorganised Tories.
*The EU is collapsing and Farron wants a re-run of the referendum , or its equivalent. Political suicide.
small local successes are not necessarily a good indicator but UKIP has seduced very many LibDem waverers it seems.

SINJUN

]]>