Labour and Plaid Cymru talks have made progress, but what will their deal look like?

A second vote to elect the first minister is likely to take place tomorrow


Nicola Sturgeon is today expected to be confirmed by the Scottish Parliament as its nominee for First Minister, while in Wales things may be coming to a head.

Following last week’s bizarre vote, in which Plaid Cymru’s Leanne Wood gained the support of the Conservatives and UKIP to secure the same number of Assembly votes as Labour’s Carwyn Jones to be the nominee for First Minister, Plaid and Labour Groups at the Assembly will today consider the outcome of talks held between the two parties.

In a statement issued yesterday following talks led by Labour’s Finance Minister, Jane Hutt and senior Plaid AM, Simon Thomas two parties noted that following ‘a positive few days of discussions’ negotiations between the parties were at an end which, they added, had led to ‘good progress’ being made.

The statement went on to note that the leaderships of each party would put the outcome of the talks to their respective AMs today, with a view to the Assembly holding a second vote to nominate a First Minister tomorrow.

This all leaves a lot still to be answered, namely what the basis of any deal really is.

There are likely to be two options, neither of which will lead to Plaid AMs finding their feet around the cabinet table.

The first is a loose supply and confidence arrangement that would see Plaid supporting Labour to get Budgets passed and on any no-confidence votes that may or may not occur. Under such a scenario Plaid will probably seek early sight of budgets and legislation to help shape them.

The second potential option would be for Plaid to make a series of policy demands to be traded in for support for the Government. One policy area in particular that Plaid is thought likely to be pursing is its proposals for improvements to the M4 to be made via the Blue Route or a variation of it, rather than Labour’s proposals for a new motorway south of Newport to ease congestion.

AMs have until 2 June to agree on a nominee for First Minister, otherwise they will face fresh elections.

Ed Jacobs is a contributing editor at Left Foot Forward

Like this article? Left Foot Forward relies on support from readers to sustain our progressive journalism. Can you become a supporter for £5 a month?

2 Responses to “Labour and Plaid Cymru talks have made progress, but what will their deal look like?”

  1. John Woods

    I am surprised that Plaid actually associated themselves, in any way, with UKIP and I feel that their supporters will be as disappointed with that move as I am (an Irishman living in England for the past 56 years). Social Democracy is on the retreat everywhere, under the strains of the so-called market economy but in reality under the strains of cheap labour in China and elsewhere in the Far East and the threats of being overwhelmed by migration into Europe. Plaid should be in partnership with Labour, as should the SNP, not seen as a different party but as a nationalist form of Social Democracy. I hope Labour in Wales manage to include at least one member of Plaid around the Cabinet table.

  2. Shaun Cohen

    As argued elsewhere, what we need is a federal Britain, Labour in Wales should include Plaid within the cabinet. Of course Plaid like any other party is not homogoneous but what is going on when they can align with the Tories with UKIP. This must not be allowed to happen.

Leave a Reply