Doctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched

As the BMA gathers for its annual conference in Cardiff, a new survey has found that of 5,000 Welsh doctors questioned, 86% said they prefer working in Wales.

As David Cameron has persistently used Prime Minister’s Questions to accuse the Welsh government of being the only administration cutting their health budget, today’s news that doctors prefer working in Wales than England will give him food for thought. As the UK British Medical Association meets this week for its annual conference in Cardiff, new survey data by the BMA in Wales has found that of 5,000 Welsh doctors questioned, 86% said they prefer working in Wales.

As the results were published, Dr Andrew Dearden, chairman of the BMA in Wales, explained:

“Doctors in Wales remain loyal to the principles set out for the NHS by Aneurin Bevan. Consecutive Welsh Governments have diminished the role of the private sector from the NHS, and the purchaser/provider split no longer operates.

“This was the right decision for doctors, and the right decision for patients – meeting the needs of everyone and free at the point of delivery.

“We really believe that Wales has it all – doctors can work in attractive surroundings offering excellent facilities and professional support, with the added benefits of a quality lifestyle – reasonably priced housing, good schools and access to beautiful countryside.

“Wales is a clear winner when it comes to aligning career development with work-life balance.”

In a statement reacting to the results, Health Minister, Lesley Griffiths was keen to point out the differences between England and Wales, emphasising the Welsh approach of collaborative working rather than competition. She argued:

“I’m delighted that our approach to providing healthcare is backed by the BMA and frontline doctors. Our vision for the NHS in Wales is very different to that being pursued by the Government in England.

“Indeed, our approach is true to the principles of Aneurin Bevan – a health service that is free at the point of need. In particular, unlike the NHS in England, we favour an integrated system which focuses on collaboration and cooperation to drive up standards, rather than a marketplace driven by competition.

“As Wales’ Health Minister, I am committed to working tirelessly to build on the progress that has already been made to ensure that the health service in Wales can compare with the best in the world.”

Its comes as the British Medical Journal has called on the UK Government to ditch is entire health bill as its flaws increasingly become obvious. In an editorial, the Journal concludes:

“In January we judged it too early to let the Health and Social Care Bill out of the lab. Its proposals had no clear rationale, lacked coherence, and looked like costing more than they would save. Since then, the bill’s flaws have become only more obvious.

“Instead of further tinkering, it would be better for the NHS, the government, and the people of England to sweep the bill’s mangled remains into an unmarked grave and move on.”

16 Responses to “Doctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched”

  1. David Dubost

    Doctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched: //bit.ly/j96E4R reports @EdJacobs1985

  2. Ed Jacobs

    RT @leftfootfwd: Doctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched //t.co/UeK9x9f

  3. Emma

    Doctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched: //bit.ly/j96E4R reports @EdJacobs1985

  4. Brian Moylan

    RT @edjacobs1985: #Doctors prefer #Wales to #England as #BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched //bit.ly/mTNDAT #ukpolitics #nhs

  5. Watching You

    Doctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched: //bit.ly/j96E4R reports @EdJacobs1985

  6. Robert

    Now I know why the bloody waiting times are going up to almost Thatcher levels these doctors are out looking at butterflies in the dam country side.

    Also the amount of begging we have to to go through to get a single NHS dentist, yes of course we get for now free prescriptions but how long that will last god knows.

    I think this is bullshit

  7. DrKMJ

    RT @leftfootfwd: Doctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched: //bit.ly/j96E4R reports @EdJacobs1985

  8. Chris Wallace

    Not surprised in the slightest @leftfootfwd: Doctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched //t.co/aytkMMi

  9. LabourWebsitesCnnect

    Not surprised in the slightest @leftfootfwd: Doctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched //t.co/aytkMMi

  10. mr. Sensible

    The government gets itself in to a bigger and bigger mess on the NHS day by day.

  11. 13eastie

    I’m sure readers would be intrigued to know who, of the posters and commentators here so predisposed to putting words into doctors’ mouths, are actually practising doctors themselves?

  12. Doctors ‘prefer Wales to England’ – BBC News

    […] 'happier' to be working in Wales than England amid proposed NHS changesWalesOnlineDoctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditchedLeft Foot […]

  13. scandalousbill

    13 Eastie,

    You say:

    “I’m sure readers would be intrigued to know who, of the posters and commentators here so predisposed to putting words into doctors’ mouths, are actually practising doctors themselves?”

    This has to be one of you most irrelevant statements yet.

    If you read the OP, it seems that ” Dr Andrew Dearden, chairman of the BMA in Wales” might suggest commentary by a practising doctor. It also strikes me that the BMA who are defined ,. (//www.bma.org.uk) “as an independent trade union, the BMA is the voice for doctors and medical students in the UK.” have much more credibility on this subject than you.

    How are these in any way “so predisposed to putting words into doctors’ mouths, or should we now call you Dr. 13Eastie?

  14. Daniel Pitt

    Doctors prefer Wales to England as BMJ calls for Health Bill to be ditched: //t.co/FbJctTP #ConDemNation #saveourNHS

  15. Scotland losing nurses as public sector shrinks | Left Foot Forward

    […] warn of thousands of job losses to come in the health service in Northern Ireland, and doctors making clear they prefer the way the NHS is working in Wales rather than England, with official figures in […]

  16. Look Left – Up to 10 million face starvation in Horn of Africa | Left Foot Forward

    […] Nick Clegg and Andrew Lansley to “bury” the controversial health bill, doctors resoundingly outlined their preference for the NHS in Wales rather than England. Commenting on the survey results, Dr. […]

Leave a Reply