Brexit shambles: leaving EU impact studies don’t even exist, the Tories just admitted

David Davis just said the government has not investigated the economic impact of Brexit -- they've been lying to Parliament all along.

David Davis just told a Parliamentary committee that papers studying the economic impact of Brexit – that he claimed just weeks ago looked at the effects of leaving the EU in “excruciating detail” – don’t actually exist. Could Brexit get any more shambolic?

The Brexit secretary said this morning the government has not conducted the sector-by-sector economic assessments on the impact of leaving the EU, after having promised he was doing so just weeks ago.

Davis said that such studies would “not necessarily be informative”.

This is despite him saying last year that the government were “in the midst of carrying out about 57 sets of analyses, each of which has implications for individual parts of 85% of the economy.”

Quizzing Davis at the Brexit select committee this morning, Labour MP Hilary Benn asked:

“Did the government undertake an assessment of leaving the customs union before the cabinet took that decision?”

And Davis responded:

“Not a quantitative one, no.”

Then Davis was asked to confirm whether the government had compiled assessments on the impact of Brexit on three different industries: automotive, financial services and aerospace. Mr Davis responded:

“No to all of them”.

Davis has effectively admitted that the government decided to leave the customs union without a proper analysis of the economic impact.

If the papers don’t exist, as Davis now claims, the government will have been misleading Parliament, after having claimed they were studying the economic impact in “excruciating detail”.

The Liberal Democrats immediately accused the Brexit secretary of “misleading parliament from the start” and “being completely blasé about the threat Brexit poses to our NHS, economy and young people”.

Liberal Democrat MP Wera Hobhouse, who sits on the Brexit Select Committee, said:

“It is unbelievable that these long-trumpeted impact assessments don’t even exist, meaning the government has no idea what their Brexit plans will do to the country.”

Tim Roache, GMB General Secretary said: “It’s remarkable that Ministers have decided that they haven’t done Brexit impact assessments after all.

“That’s not what they’ve been telling us for the last few months, so either they’ve been leading us up the garden path or they’re playing fast and loose with people’s livelihoods, communities and the economy. It’s unforgivable recklessness.

“It’s time that Ministers put people’s jobs first and urgently conduct and publish the impact assessments so people can plan for the future. Without them, we’re flying blind,” he added.

So it seems appears even the government don’t know the economic impact Brexit could wreak — and they’ve been hiding this from us all along. Who would have thought Brexit could get any messier?

Like this article? Sign up to Left Foot Forward's weekday email for the latest progressive news and comment - and support campaigning journalism by making a donation today.

4 Responses to “Brexit shambles: leaving EU impact studies don’t even exist, the Tories just admitted”

  1. William

    What can one expect from this shambolic, disorganised bunch of liars. The arrogance of these so called “representatives” of the British public is becoming more and more blatent. Surely we need another General Election soon to try to rid Parliament of this self serving crowd of power hungry idiots.

  2. Elizabeth Chell

    The only way forward is a General Election sooner rather than later to get the so called “representatives of the people” out of office. Insert a few competent people like Keir Starmer, Hilary Benn, Chuka Ummuna, etc in to help clear up the mess the Tories are making.

  3. Alasdair Macdonald

    He might well have lied, but it is up to Parliament to decide to take any action. Given the Government majority including a huffy and miffed DUP and abstentions from Labour Leavers, then a motion to sanction Mr Davis will fall. What can be done then?
    Given that the coup d’etat effected by the small wealthy coterie who bankrolled Brexit is nearing its end game of ‘Britain crashing out’, their desired outcome, they will pillage the state, remove rights and live in their estates guarded by their private security armies.

  4. Jimmy Glesga

    Yes pay beaurocrats to sit and make up future scenarios. Really a stupid anti brexit comment from Hillary Benn. The bemoaners are so desperate.

Leave a Reply