Britons’ fear of migration is not only misplaced - it distracts us from bigger issues
I recently attended an event organised by the Foreign Policy Centre in partnership with the European Commission’s representation in the UK. The title could hardly be more topical: ‘Examining the EU’s democratic legitimacy.’
It really was about Brexit, like nearly every political debate in the UK for months if not years.
Hilary Benn MP delivered an eloquent keynote speech about the need of parliamentary oversight of the divorce process.
After him, other articulate voices from both chambers expressed their thoughts about the value of democracy, the history of Britain in Europe and the meaning of national and parliamentary sovereignty.
Conservatives, Labour, Liberal Democrats and SNP had at least one voice in the panel; so did UKIP with its only MP (to Nigel Farage’s eternal sorrow), Douglas Carswell.
Judging by the interventions during the Q&A, had the referendum been held only in that room, Britain would have never chosen to leave; in fact, Conservatives would probably be a marginal force.
‘How did we get to this point?’ an incredulous audience asked with different words and tones.
‘It’s immigration, stupid!’ The recurrent hypothesis was unsurprisingly put forward by Carswell. It went unchallenged. It sinks in. It stays. And it stains.
Immigration is constantly portrayed as the source of many problems despite the lack of evidence. Immigrants pay more in taxes than they receive in benefits.
They (we) contribute to support the welfare state in this country, not to speak of the number of professionals that work in the NHS and other essential public services and in the private sector.
Research shows that immigrants from both EU-15 and eastern Europe give to society more than they receive from the state. Similar phenomena are noticeable in many other rich countries.
The fear of migration is not supported by a simple reality check, but someone could counterattack along these lines:
‘The overall economy and even public finances may benefit from it, but disenfranchised working class people in post industrial constituencies are paying the price.’
I would take this point seriously: Not everyone benefits equally from free trade and freedom of movement. But the connection between rising inequality and the desire to control national borders is not as self-evident as some are succeeding in making us believe.
Latest available EU statistics from 2015 indicate that 13 per cent of inhabitants in the UK are foreign-born. Other countries have a higher share: Ireland (16.2 per cent), Austria (17.2 per cent) or Sweden (16.4 per cent).
Still, according to a recent poll by Ipsos Mori, Britain remains the country where immigration is reported as the most significant worry: It is so for 42 per cent of the people. Germany goes second with 41 per cent and Sweden third with 33 per cent.
But let’s take my home country as a point of reference: Spain. The number of foreign-born inhabitants lies at 12.7 per cent, not far behind the UK. However, immigration is the most unsettling issue only for nine per cent of the population.
We are talking about a country where about 20 per cent of working age people are unemployed (it reached 25 per cent in the worst years of the financial crisis), and a society that only one generation ago barely knew what foreign nationals looked like, apart from pictures of blond blue-eyed northern Europeans on the Mediterranean coastline.
Unscrupulous media groups and wily politicians have fruitfully spread the rumour that foreigners are to blame for the misfortunes of working people. This exercise of cheap scaremongering is proving very appealing.
There is an urgent need for a counter-narrative to set the record straight. The political class in this country is greatly responsible for the unfounded and disproportionate level of fear of foreigners.
While some keep banging on about it with impunity, others remain silent and refuse to challenge their views in public.
Poverty and social inequality is only the fourth worst worry for the British public (29 per cent). Foreigners are easy scapegoats, but this country needs to start hitting the right nail soon.
Koldo Casla is a PhD candidate in European and International Studies at King’s College London, and a Policy officer at Just Fair. He writes in a personal capacity.
See: Other countries don’t worry this much about immigration – why does Britain?
See: Six weirdest things David ‘refugees’ teeth’ Davies MP has ever said (that we know of)
To reach hundreds of thousands of new readers and to make the biggest impact we can in the next general election, we need to grow our donor base substantially.
That's why in 2024, we are seeking to generate 150 additional regular donors to support Left Foot Forward's work.
We still need another 124 people to donate to hit the target. You can help. Donate today.
11 Responses to “Foreigners are easy scapegoats, but bashing them won’t fix our real problems”
NHSGP
The overall economy and even public finances may benefit from it, but disenfranchised working class people in post industrial constituencies are paying the price.’
=============
It doesn’t.
The UK needs to cherry pick the best economic migrants, and not pick cherry pickers.
Then the concerns over migration disappear.
1. No criminals.
2. Net contributors only
3. No discrimination.
The real problem is the 30% the state is spending on debts.
UberCon
When the immigration obsessives admit that some immigration is good and some is bad we will be able to have a sensible discussion regarding who should be allowed to move to the UK.
Also, when we blame corporations and compliant politicians for fixing the labour market in their favour, immigration obsessives should not hide behind migrants and allow migrants to take the flak.
Michael WALKER
Another writer who lives in a bubble – in London (no surprise then) – and cannot understand what others are thinking.
I voted Remain but I know many who voted “Leave”. Basically they don’t trust their politicians, see the EU as bureaucratic and interfering , find unelected politicians lecturing them unacceptable and dislike ignorant based Londoners sneering at them.They have also missed out in the boom in house and asset prices.
Unsurprisingly, when asked to vote for “more of the same”, they rebel..
Zac
Michael, how about this. I don’t trust politicians and I don’t trust the EU. I also happen to live in LONDON, where I was born and have always lived, and where that boom in house and asset prices is destroying my community. A boom in house prices isn’t good when you rent, which everyone I know in London does because it’s just too expensive to buy. We’re not a bunch of metropolitan elite sitting on a pile of assets, some of us are trying to get by and finding it hard.
Immigrants aren’t causing my problems, the government is. Speak for yourself.
Mick
Also, the Left whine and whine and whine, then fail. First, see the excellent comments above. Then note that when the Dubs Amendment bullied the Government into changing its policy on Syrian asylum, the ‘children’ we let in are actually butch and strapping! And then the public are sceptical.
And when it comes to immigration policy, the Left are surprisingly capitalist. Especially Corbyn and Abbot, whose policy of ‘let in as many as possible and sod the checks’ can only increase competition for jobs and houses, not to mention straining services. (Indeed, the only reason immigrants ‘save’ the NHS is because you need a pile more staff for a pile more people.)
I still vaguely remember that letter some council leaders wrote to Brown, Cameron and Clegg about how their area just can’t take any more. Clearly, Labour and the Left still can’t listen.