Are the Tories really ‘streets ahead on gender equality’? The numbers say no

Just one in five Conservative MPs are women

conbenches
Image: UK Parliament

The hype over Britain’s second female Prime Minister should not distract from the fact that our politics remains extremely unequal.

Both Labour and the Conservatives bear a large share of responsibility, and neither is entitled to crow over the other on the grounds of gender equality.

But that’s what the Tories and their supporters have done, exemplified by the Telegraph’s claim that the Conservatives are ‘streets ahead’ of Labour on gender equality.

Many on the left have echoed the critique. Jess Philips MP says that Labour ‘should be ashamed’.

It is a cause for shame that Labour has never had an elected female leader, but the narrative that establishes leadership as the only marker of equality — and the Tories as the equality party — should be questioned.

We should point out, for example, that throughout her time as prime minister, Margaret Thatcher never had more than 17 female colleagues —  4.5 per cent of her parliamentary party.

And that didn’t look set to change under the Major government either. It was Labour that established an expectation of greater gender balance, when it elected 101 women MPs in 1997, to the Conservatives’ 13.

It wasn’t until 2010 and David Cameron’s attempts at modernisation that the Tories got above 20 women MPs, jumping to 49 then and 68 in 2015.

a women MPs by party

                                                                                                                 Graph via UK Political Info

At present, 21 per cent of Tory MPs are women, compared to 43 per cent of Labour MPs.

Since 1945, Labour has had over 700 female MPs. The Conservatives have had just over 300.

It is a powerful symbol to have a female prime minister, but political equality runs a lot deeper than that.

Additionally, if the Conservatives are going to claim credit for their female leadership, they need to point to the party attitudes or structures that encourage female leadership.

At present, it has no official policy (like Labour’s all-women shortlists) to ensure a consistent increase in its number of female candidates. This creates a pipeline problem whereby there simply aren’t enough experienced women to take senior positions.

As a result, David Cameron has struggled to achieve a cabinet that is one-third female.

Moreover, looking at Theresa May and Andrea Leadsom’s careers (to say nothing of Margaret Thatcher’s), they have succeeded in spite of, not because of their party.

Before being elected, both were nominated, contested and lost elections in safe Labour constituencies despite, in Leadsom’s case, being one of David Cameron’s A-Listers.

And it’s difficult to claim that this leadership contest reflects a long-term commitment to equality when for years the two favourite candidates for leader have, as usual, been upper-class men.

The all-female leadership race is a product of George Osborne, Michael Gove and Boris Johnson making huge unforced errors, not a sudden change of attitude.

Labour obviously needs to do better, but no one should accept the narrative that the Tories are suddenly the party of gender equality.

Niamh Ní Mhaoileoin is editor of Left Foot Forward. Follow her on Twitter.

4 Responses to “Are the Tories really ‘streets ahead on gender equality’? The numbers say no”

  1. Richard MacKinnon

    “Labour obviously needs to do better, but no one should accept the narrative that the Tories are suddenly the party of gender equality.” Twist the figures any way you want. Perception is everything. Picture this, the next PMQs, Jeremy v Theresa or Jeremy v Andrea. Any preference Niamh?

  2. Imran Khan

    Who exactly asked the question at the head of this articl?. It seems to be the writer herself who then answers her own question that, as far as I know, nobody else has asked. Ther are actually many subjects that are worthy of an article without inventing them.

  3. Richard MacKinnon

    Imran,
    The question of gender equality is an obsession with Labour especially with Labour woman. The contortions Labour will go through to make the numbers balance is farcical. Its hard to credit that Labour has rewritten candidate selection rules to ensure a woman is selected. But its a fact. In comparison the Tories selection criteria is, who is the best candidate. Is it any wonder Labour are where they are.

Leave a Reply