Daily Mail-owned commuter rag implies strike is about holidays. It isn't.
The free morning newspaper Metro, read by commuters in London and elsewhere, has packed more myths about today’s tube strike into a few sentences than seems possible.
Today’s headline reads:
‘Commuter fury at strikers with 52 days holiday‘
Holiday time is a big part of the coverage of this strike – including in the Telegraph, the Express, and the Daily Mail (which shares an owner with the Metro).
It appears to have been raised by Boris Johnson to discredit the strike, and his pals in the right-wing press have helpfully caught his drift.
A few points on the Metro story blazing out of free papers across the capital:
1. Train staff are not striking over holiday time.
Today’s strike is the latest in a series of strikes (the last was a month ago) over changes in the terms of train staff’s employment. Primarily, they are concerned that people who already work through the night and on weekends will have to accept more late shifts with the introduction of 24 hour tube services in September.
They are also opposing cuts to staff at stations, which they say will damage the service for commuters, and reject a crumbs-from-the-table offer on pay increases in an economy we are told is ‘growing’.
2. Not all train staff have 52 days holiday
There is a tendency to see what train staff with the best pay and conditions are receiving and take this as representative of all train staff, from drivers to cleaners. Interestingly, this method is never applied to other businesses.
Perhaps this is because in many industries the idea of the best and worst paid workers uniting in an act of solidarity is hard to imagine.
3. Not all tube staff are drivers – most earn nothing like £50,000
See point 2. Many tube workers earn less than half of this figure. Still you’ll see it bandied about everywhere.
4. If you want more holiday time or pay, join or form a trade union
52 days a year? £50,000 salary? Everyone should be so lucky! Instead of begrudging train staff, why not organise and demand this for yourselves and your colleagues?
There is a larger issue worth noticing. The Metro recently published a full page advert from Transport for London putting their side of the story. They then interviewed miffed commuters, presumably with questions like: ‘Do you think it’s right that tube drivers on £50k should strike?’
The answers were as predictable as they could have hoped. (And if they weren’t, the paper could have simply picked the ones they liked.) So there’s your ‘commuter fury’.
The other element worth noticing is the large showbiz story dominating the same front page today, not surprising perhaps from a paper owned by the Daily Mail group. The cult of celebrity – effectively veneration of aristocracy – is ever present in papers that bash trade unions.
Mail boss Viscount Rothermere: not your friend
Such is the position of elite institutions like media companies (where only a select few get to work) posing as the carrier of the voice of the ordinary person, in this case against the bully train unions.
This fake populism from a media group headed by a tax-dodging Viscount is a handy cover for turning working people against one another. ‘Why have these greedy train drivers got more than me? My day has been disrupted by their selfishness’ etc.
Meanwhile, relatively democratic institutions like trade unions, which have a far better claim to speak for ‘ordinary people’, are denied their chance to state their case, and denounced – indirectly – by a newspaper that pretends to be your friend.
Adam Barnett is a staff writer at Left Foot Forward. Follow MediaWatch on Twitter
DONATE to support MediaWatch here.
Read more:
Anti-union press wants train staff to act like robots. But who is the real bully here?
The Sun won’t tell you why train staff are striking. So we will
Sign up for our weekly email by clicking here.
To reach hundreds of thousands of new readers and to make the biggest impact we can in the next general election, we need to grow our donor base substantially.
That's why in 2024, we are seeking to generate 150 additional regular donors to support Left Foot Forward's work.
We still need another 124 people to donate to hit the target. You can help. Donate today.
16 Responses to “Tube strike: your free Metro is spreading myths to discredit the strike”
Selohesra
Aus 29-6 – these strikers will become heroes for those ‘working from home’ today
TN
Adam, is your only purpose on here to navel gaze parts of the media you don’t like for being so mean and nasty lol? Try commuting in London, relying on the Tube. Stop playing dumb as Londoners don’t need you wet leftists (and centre leftists) telling them how to think. This strike is based on causing trouble and is based on greed. The RMT is crossing the line.
Z
You’re on a website called left foot forward. I suggest you go back to the Daily Mail or Daily Express comments section, we don’t want your tripe here.
Graham Lester George
I don’t know what you do for a living Adam, but unless you were born into wealth and privilege, then any employment rights and the rate of pay that you have, will be because people – union members – either took strike action to win them, or they were negotiated for by union representatives. Make no mistake, your employers want to reduce your conditions and your pay, and they will if they can get away with it. The whole raison d’être of capitalism is to buy low and sell high. You’re labour is one of the things that they buy.
Sylar
Make a sentence out of the following words. Bike, your, on.