Prospect of EU exit boosts support for Scottish Independence

With the CBI having already warned of the risks to industry of Britain no longer being at the heart of the European Union, a further uncomfortable truth surrounding the Conservative Party's increasingly isolationist rhetoric is now becoming apparent.

With the CBI having already warned of the risks to industry of Britain no longer being at the heart of the European Union, a further uncomfortable truth surrounding the Conservative Party’s increasingly isolationist rhetoric is now becoming apparent.

Polling conducted by Panelbase for the Sunday Times and Real Radio Scotland has indicated that faced with the prospect of the UK leaving the European Union, support for Scotland becoming an independent country rockets in favour of yes.

Asked “should Scotland be an independent country?” 36 per cent said yes with 44 per cent answering no, and 20 per cent saying they did not know.

Presented however with the question “how would you be likely to vote in next year’s Scottish independence referendum if the UK was looking likely to vote to withdraw from the EU?”, 44 per cent said they would be likely to vote yes, matched by 44 per cent likely to vote no, while 12 per cent said they did not know.

Outlining the impact that uncertainty over EU membership is having on the prospects for Scotland breaking away from the union (with England that is), Ivor Knox, director of Panelbase explained:

“The prospect of the UK leaving the EU has little impact on those Scots who have formed a view on independence, but among undecided voters three times as many tend to support independence as oppose it, under those circumstances.”

Accusing Westminster of being dragged along by the UKIP agenda, SNP MSP Clare Adamson said of the polling:

“Plans for the UK to exit Europe change the terms of the debate – putting yes and no neck and neck at 44 per cent – because the Westminster system getting dragged along by a Ukip agenda underlines that it is out of touch with Scotland. It shows that only a yes vote puts the people of Scotland in charge of our own future.”

Having declared his “passionate” belief and support for the union between Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom, one wonders how David Cameron’s commitment to this measures up against a European policy which is clearly turning voters away from the union in this country he is seemingly so committed to.

Nationally meanwhile, attempts by a plethora of Conservative ministers to argue that the party is in fact speaking from the same page on Europe is failing to convince the public, with a number of polls over the weekend clearly showing that the voters feel the Tories are a divided party.

According to polling by CromRes for the Independent on Sunday and the Sunday Mirror, 57 per cent agree with the statement that “the Conservative Party is more divided over Europe now than it was when John Major was Prime Minister” compared to 14 per cent who disagree. Data by YouGov for the Sunday Times meanwhile saw 71 per cent of respondents believing that the Conservative Party is, at presented, a divided party.

4 Responses to “Prospect of EU exit boosts support for Scottish Independence”

  1. Chris Brown

    What impact will Denis Healey’s revelations have on the referendum campaign? His statements don’t just reflect badly on the Wilson government, but on every government since then – including the current one.

  2. Andrew Stone

    The reality is of course that no one on both sides of the debate knows what will happen after the vote. This is something that has to be explained to the voters.

    The vote is about Scottish independence – not the SNP – though the No camp would very much like arguement to go in that direction.

    Scots have a choice between voting for a government they control ‘YES’ or letting the likes of Nigel Farage and David Cameron control Scotland.

    The No campaign, with there support from Canary Wharf and Westminster will do everything they can to distract from that debate. EU, tax credits, national debt are all part of distracting the debate away from ‘Do the Scots want Nigel Farage and David Cameron’ which they neither support or vote for.

    Whatever you think of the SNP and Alec Salmon in an independent Scotland Scots get the option of voting them out. There is no such option if you vote no. You get Nigel Farage and David Cameron.

    The main problem is fear, not the economic arguements, which are unchallengable when you bring up the example of Norway.

    It’s a vote about independence – not the EU,

  3. Andrew Stone

    And the idea of Gordon Brown, David Cameron, Nigel Farage and Nick Clegg all urging support of a No is really scary. Reminds me of when Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin were mates and the formation Nazi – Soviet pact.

    Any of the numerous Poles in this country will tell you what that was all about.

  4. Chris Brown

    Interestingly the BBC did not mention Healey’s statement at all, but devoted the entirety of the Newsnight Scotland segment to the fact that the GA had voted in favour of gay ministers. Good job the BBC is not partisan on the independence issue…..

Leave a Reply