Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum

Two reports this week provide a harrowing snapshot of life in the UK for women who seek asylum here, writes Dr Russell Hargrave of Asylum Aid.

E-mail-sign-up Donate

 

.

Russell Hargrave is the Communications and Public Affairs Officer at Asylum Aid

report published yesterday provides a harrowing snapshot of life in the UK for women who seek asylum here.

Asylum-seekersOf the 72 women interviewed by Women for Refugee Women, 48 per cent had fled their home countries after being raped, while 49 per cent had been arrested or imprisoned.  All told, 66 per cent had experienced gender-related persecution.

These are women fleeing unimaginable horrors – yet only three were recognised as refugees. The overwhelming majority were disbelieved by the UK Border Agency, which so far remains resistant to any attempts to overhaul its entrenched ‘culture of disbelief’.

What are the policy failings that allow this situation to arise, and how widespread is the problem?

One attempt to answer this question is provided in Asylum Aid’s own report, Gender-related asylum claims in Europe (pdf), published today in collaboration with our European partners in Spain, France, Italy and Hungary. The report looks at all forms of gender-related persecution, but focuses primarily on women.

Drawing on interviews with women who have fled persecution in 27 different countries, it concludes that there are vast, worrying disparities in the way different EU member states handle gender-related asylum claims. As a result, women are not guaranteed anything close to consistent, gender-sensitive treatment when they seek protection in Europe.

 


See also:

Gulf between asylum and benefit support leaves thousands of children in severe poverty 13 Apr 2012

The government’s Violence Against Women strategy ignores women seeking asylum 8 Mar 2012

Lifting the lid on child detention 18 Feb 2010


 

Among the nine states researched – the UK, Belgium, France, Hungary, Italy, Malta, Romania, Spain, and Sweden – there are glaring discrepancies in national asylum practice. The protection available to women in one state may be wholly absent across the border. Spain, for example, fails to recognise trafficking as a form of persecution.

Neither is Forced Genital Mutilation (FGM) always recognised as persecution in France, Malta, and Romania.

On a strategic level, fewer than half the states have adopted gender guidelines so are missing a crucial tool for guiding asylum decision-makers on gender-related claims. One country, Romania, fails entirely to publish asylum statistics broken down by gender, despite legal obligations to do so.

There is a smattering of good practice from which all states could learn. In Malta, for example, the burden of proof is lowered for women who are severely traumatised. Authorities in the UK and Belgium provide childcare during most asylum interviews: this is crucial, to ensure that no mother is forced to choose between disclosing distressing details in front of her children and holding back information central to her asylum claim.

Nonetheless there is a lot of lobbying ahead, here and across Europe, to develop good practice and strip away the bad.

In case anyone needed a reminder of what was at stake, one of the speakers at the Refused launch was Helen Bamber, the doughtiest of all campaigners for asylum rights. “How do we respond,” she asked rhetorically, “to those to whom we owe nothing?” 

Answering this question positively has helped Europe define itself in modern times. And now more than ever, our answer must include ensuring basic standards of dignity and safety for women who flee to Europe, regardless of the state to which they turn for help.

 


Sign-up to our weekly email • Donate to Left Foot Forward

35 Responses to “Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum”

  1. Soupy One

    Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum, writes Dr Russell Hargrave from @AsylumAid: //t.co/Mj5HtuMg

  2. John Scovell

    Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum, writes Dr Russell Hargrave from @AsylumAid: //t.co/Mj5HtuMg

  3. Asylum Aid

    "It's time to develop good practice & strip away the bad" AsylumAid with @leftfootfwd on women, asylum & the EU //t.co/eXUDM0NM

  4. Jane Greenstock

    "It's time to develop good practice & strip away the bad" AsylumAid with @leftfootfwd on women, asylum & the EU //t.co/eXUDM0NM

  5. Nina Murray

    "It's time to develop good practice & strip away the bad" AsylumAid with @leftfootfwd on women, asylum & the EU //t.co/eXUDM0NM

  6. leftlinks

    Left Foot Forward – Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/8SZzFarh

  7. Press Gang Leeds

    "It's time to develop good practice & strip away the bad" AsylumAid with @leftfootfwd on women, asylum & the EU //t.co/eXUDM0NM

  8. Born írt:

    #bornirt Poor standards persist across <b>Europe</b> for women seeking asylum: One attempt… //t.co/mrRHEKzc

  9. 1001001

    RT @HelenBamber Barriers to women seeking asylum article, Helen Bamber: How do we respond to those to …@leftfootfwd //t.co/7qxviodP

  10. SJ

    Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum, writes Dr Russell Hargrave from @AsylumAid: //t.co/Mj5HtuMg

  11. Pucci D

    Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum, writes Dr Russell Hargrave from @AsylumAid: //t.co/Mj5HtuMg

  12. Womens Association

    //t.co/gsbDNv4V Poor standards for women seeking asylum. 🙁

  13. Heaven Crawley

    "It's time to develop good practice & strip away the bad" AsylumAid with @leftfootfwd on women, asylum & the EU //t.co/eXUDM0NM

  14. Saoirse Brady

    "It's time to develop good practice & strip away the bad" AsylumAid with @leftfootfwd on women, asylum & the EU //t.co/eXUDM0NM

  15. Nick

    RT @leftfootfwd: Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/FKbhJHYn

  16. MaltaBreakingNews

    MaltaNews Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum …: Among the nine states researched – … //t.co/Ldkegjno

  17. Francis N

    "It's time to develop good practice & strip away the bad" AsylumAid with @leftfootfwd on women, asylum & the EU //t.co/eXUDM0NM

  18. Born írt:

    #bornirt Poor standards persist across <b>Europe</b> for women seeking asylum <b>…</b>… //t.co/aunWzFyU

  19. Freedom from Torture

    RT @leftfootfwd: Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/T1SCJ9qK from @AsylumAid

  20. Christel Querton

    @4refugeewomen Thank you for sharing, have you seen this piece too by Russell Hargrave @AsylumAid //t.co/yFMV1VHu

  21. Bill Dishington

    RT @leftfootfwd: Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/T1SCJ9qK from @AsylumAid

  22. WomenforRefugeeWomen

    Our report covered in Lef Foot Forward //t.co/uA2XoqJk

  23. WomenforRefugeeWomen

    Our report covered in @leftfootfwd //t.co/uA2XoqJk
    Thanks!

  24. Women's Refugee Comm

    What we're reading: "Poor standards persist across Europe for #women seeking asylum" //t.co/DiCONB8u #refugees

  25. Rosanna Tussey

    What we're reading: "Poor standards persist across Europe for #women seeking asylum" //t.co/DiCONB8u #refugees

  26. SISGI Group

    RT @wrcommission What we're reading: "Poor standards persist across Europe for #women seeking asylum" //t.co/QpBKcHnq #refugees

  27. Julia Roberts

    RT @leftfootfwd: Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/4QPfhxX5

  28. Women Embrace

    RT @leftfootfwd: Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/Z4WjcDnT

  29. Lou Estelle Greenoff

    “@FreefromTorture: RT @leftfootfwd: Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/YgkL1Yvr from @AsylumAid”

  30. IAFR

    Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/UUYIpFgF

  31. The Boaz Trust

    Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/ENjhlT7A

  32. WomenforRefugeeWomen

    Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/ENjhlT7A

  33. phillip cole

    Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum //t.co/ENjhlT7A

  34. BBC coverage pushes the government to focus on the horrors of FGM in the UK | Left Foot Forward

    […] See also: • Poor standards persist across Europe for women seeking asylum 30 May […]

Leave a Reply