Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy?

Alex Hern looks ahead to 2012 and what the year holds for students in Britain.

Royal College of Music, one of the universities set to lose all of its teaching grant

 

The year ahead for students will be dominated by one thing: the arrival of the first cohort of students paying the new tripled fees.

The average fee for the 2012 intake stands at just a shade over £8000, with just over a third of English universities charging the maximum of £9000.

This increase has already had an enormous effect on the size and make-up of the group arriving at university. The number of UK-born students who applied to start this year fell by 15 per cent on 2011, to 133,357.

This drop is not so large when compared to 2010, however, when the number of UK born applications was 139,875. Unsurprisingly, it appears that many students who may otherwise have taken a gap year decided to go straight through to university, creating a temporary boom in 2011. We shall find out this year whether the corresponding fall is also temporary.

The actual effect that the increased fees will have on students finances also remains very up in the air.

In November last year, the government, in an attempt to lower the average fee, bribed some universities to lower what they were charging. Universities which charged less that £7500 were to be allowed to take on extra students. According to the BBC, this led to 27 universities changing their fees, even after students had applied.

Many of these fees were lowered by moving money from student support to fee waivers, which is a decision which will have far reaching effects.

For all that high tuition fees are problematic, their pernicious effects are largely long-term; they aren’t paid back until graduation, and many students won’t ever pay them back in full. With this in mind, the effect of a fee waiver is small and delayed. It could mean that the graduate will be able to stop paying back their loan at 39 rather than at 41, for instance.

This contrasts with the student support money, which is being used to pay for many of these fee waivers. This is money set aside for helping the poorest students survive through their degree. It cannot be offset, and for many students if it runs out, they have to drop out.

This change is not the only one made recently.

In late December, Times Higher Education reported that the Million+ group of ex-polytechnics was fearing cuts in the widening-participation premium, a £227 million pot allocated to universities to reflect the higher cost of teaching poorer students.

The head of the group, Pam Tatlow, said:

It has become clear in recent days that the Treasury thinks that cutting the widening-participation premium is a ‘saving’ worth making.

The final decision as to whether the grant will indeed be maintained has not yet been taken, but its cutting would follow the trend of shifting ever increasing amounts of the cost of a students education onto them.

The cuts to the block teaching grants will continue for the universities, with the government holding firm on its 2010 commitment to cut the overall teaching budget by over 40 per cent, including the entirety of the teaching budget of over 20 universities, from the LSE and SOAS to the Courtauld Institute and Royal College of Music.

This crunch will combine with the research council funding cuts to make 2012 very tight indeed for a number of universities.

If they can make it through to the first payments of the higher tuition fees, they should be OK, but with them not due until February 2013, it will not be surprising if one or more universities face a very difficult financial situation this year.

The year may not be rosy for the universities’ finances, but there may be some positive changes on the horizon. By January 20th, we should know the results of UCAS’ public consultation on changing the university application process.

As Laura McInerney wrote when the changes were first proposed:

As exams are now scanned and sent electronically to examiners, alongside online scrutiny and normalisation of exam marks, the process is now much quicker than ever before.

If students began their exams a few weeks earlier – at the beginning rather than end of May – the results could be ready before colleges close at the end of July enabling students to apply for university over the summer clear in the knowledge of their grades.

While the solution sounds so sensible one could be forgiven for thinking it should have been implemented five years ago with the introduction of electronic examination processes, one must consider why it was that Labour – who first suggested this change in 2004 – failed to follow through to success.

There are many potential problems with the changes, but if they are taken into account, the best-case scenario could be an application process fairer to all, and more able to cater for the least advantaged students.

Whether or not UCAS builds an acceptable replacement, for the most part 2012 looks set to be a year of hardship and strife for students and universities.

Higher tuition fees will be damaging in the long term, but the short term difficulties of the switch from a state- to student-funded higher education system are what should be most feared for the year ahead.

See also:

University applications down 9 per cent on 2011Sally Hunt, October 24th 2011

Rich kids will pay less student debt than middle classesSally Hunt, September 20th 2011

Academic super-group are more like intellectual mercenariesKevin Meagher, June 7th 2011

Universities fail the teacher testSally Hunt, March 31st 2011

The worrying lack of power of the university fair access regulatorSally Hunt, February 25th 2011

34 Responses to “Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy?”

  1. Political Planet

    Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy?: Alex Hern looks ahead to 2012 and what the year holds for studen… http://t.co/E32c8s4l

  2. Steven Fielding

    2012 looks set to be a year of hardship for students and universities: http://t.co/zjsc13bA @alexhern looks ahead.

  3. Daniel James Gillard

    2012 looks set to be a year of hardship for students and universities: http://t.co/zjsc13bA @alexhern looks ahead.

  4. Sean PdeC

    2012 looks set to be a year of hardship for students and universities: http://t.co/zjsc13bA @alexhern looks ahead.

  5. Talat Yaqoob

    2012 looks set to be a year of hardship for students and universities: http://t.co/zjsc13bA @alexhern looks ahead.

  6. Extradition Game

    RT @leftfootfwd: 2012 looks set to be a year of hardship for students and universities: http://t.co/mgs9w71J @alexhern looks ahead.

  7. Patron Press - #P2

    #UK : Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/FbQfSgrI

  8. Laurie JM Farr

    What a shame. @NottsProfSteve RT "@leftfootfwd: 2012 looks set to be a year of hardship for students + universities: http://t.co/BSCVGfBt

  9. leftlinks

    Left Foot Forward – Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/w3WzI7vh

  10. Saskia Sassen

    #UK : Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/FbQfSgrI

  11. StudentDataRecovery

    Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/llud45Sd

  12. seuss

    2012 looks set to be a year of hardship for students and universities: http://t.co/zjsc13bA @alexhern looks ahead.

  13. Janet Graham

    2012 looks set to be a year of hardship for students and universities: http://t.co/zjsc13bA @alexhern looks ahead.

  14. Eric Corijn

    The invisible hand rules science! : Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/qZEHL8Pp

  15. Jessica Alexandra

    Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy?: By January 20th, we should know the results of UCAS' public cons… http://t.co/Hs1lFBNn

  16. chris star

    Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy?
    http://t.co/Stbqfcqq

  17. Hitchin England

    RT @leftfootfwd: 2012 looks set to be a year of hardship for students and universities: http://t.co/cy5DfHiN @alexhern looks ahead.

  18. Sean Ruston

    RT @leftfootfwd: Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/9R3NYsWl

  19. Tom Flynn

    RT @leftfootfwd: Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/9R3NYsWl

  20. Joe Kirwin

    RT @leftfootfwd: Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/XQ0u0cgd

  21. Graduate News

    Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? – Left Foot Forward: Left Foot ForwardWill 2012 see the first uni… http://t.co/xv7wvp3m

  22. Ros Birch

    RT @leftfootfwd: Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/A97Z07lU

  23. ** Ali **

    Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/bSULRjXL #UK

  24. Mr. Sensible

    Well judging by what we were reading in the papers this weekend, the library fine is always an option…

  25. fírgoa

    Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? | Left Foot Forward – http://t.co/4lViTVhy

  26. Kevin Ward

    RT @leftfootfwd: Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/tbla1x0K <<< interesting article

  27. Andy

    RT @leftfootfwd: Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/DqmFVl0r

  28. cim

    and many students won’t ever pay them back in full

    Indeed, those earning less than 30k a year (real terms) will be paying back less in total than they would under the previous system because of the increase in the repayment threshold.

    Absolutely agreed that fee waivers are completely worthless except as a psychological thing and immediate student support in terms of grants, etc. is what’s needed. Good for the government’s budgeting, though.

    but the short term difficulties of the switch from a state- to student-funded higher education system

    It’s not really a switch like that, though. A genuine student-funded system as envisaged in the original Browne report would have taken away government control over student place numbers (and that would have led to some closures, long-term). The government took out all the free-market parts of that proposal, so the system remains basically state funded (but the funding amount is calculated on a “how much do you want per student” rather than a “this is what you get per student” basis).

  29. Martin Hughes

    Left Foot Forward's @alexhern asks, "Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy?" http://t.co/8hLZHzPC

  30. Budd Hall

    Left Foot Forward's @alexhern asks, "Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy?" http://t.co/8hLZHzPC

  31. Tom Hay

    Left Foot Forward's @alexhern asks, "Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy?" http://t.co/8hLZHzPC

  32. cameronsfollys

    This is a very, v-e-r-y interesting question: Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? http://t.co/Qkzjplf8 http://t.co/GLIqKfCY

  33. the faithful wife

    Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? | Left Foot Forward – http://t.co/4lViTVhy

  34. Look Left – Wonga’s student ‘scam’ comes unstuck | Left Foot Forward

    […] Will 2012 see the first university bankruptcy? – Alex Hern Share | Permalink | Leave a comment […]

Leave a Reply