Whatever Osborne’s growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse

Today's growth and borrowing forecasts are likely to be grim - they are just as likely to be over optimistic.

As part of chancellor Osborne’s Autumn Statement today, new growth predictions from the Office of Budget Responsibility (OBR) will be revealed. 

All economic roads lead back to growth – less growth means fewer jobs, stagnating or falling living standards and further pressures on public spending. Disappointing growth has also led to the coalition expecting to borrow more than Labour was projected to if it had won the 2010 election.

So analysts will be hanging on the chancellor’s words on how much he expects the economy to grow by, and how much he expects the government will have to borrow during this parliament.

But it is worth remember that, going on the track record, whatever Osborne announces as the OBR’s projections for growth are, the reality will almost certainly be worse. 

Every OBR forecast for 2011 and 2012 has been subsequently downgraded. Here we compile the OBR’s predictions for 2011 growth, along with the OECD forecast and a round up on independent forecasts collated by the Treasury, both released this month:

These have come down drastically – from 2.6% on the snap budget following the election, to 2.1% in November 2010 and then 1.7% last March. However the independent forecasters collated by the Treasury and OECD reckon that growth this year will be as low as 1% and 0.9% respectively.

Similarly OBR predictions for 2012 have been similarly downgraded if not to the same extent.

While these projections have only been reduced from 2.8% to 2.5%, the independent forecasters and the OECD say they expect UK growth of  1% and 0.5% next year.

However bad it sounds today, the reality will probably be worse.

 

 

17 Responses to “Whatever Osborne’s growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse”

  1. False Economy

    Whatever Osborne's growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse: http://t.co/hjwLms6H: writes @danielelton #as12

  2. DarkestAngel

    Whatever Osborne's growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse: http://t.co/hjwLms6H: writes @danielelton #as12

  3. Occupy International

    Whatever Osborne's growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse: http://t.co/hjwLms6H: writes @danielelton #as12

  4. Political Planet

    Whatever Osborne’s growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse: Today's growth and borrowing forecasts… http://t.co/wIbdGVN0

  5. Michael

    Whatever Osborne’s growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse I Left Foot Forward – http://t.co/vK5vtVls

  6. Anonymous

    And since you said they were cutting too fast, it would be worse under Labour.

    The problem is that even you wouldn’t take the medicine.

    That medicine is 30% cuts in public spending. That gets the deficit to zero.

    Then on top the issue of the vast off the book debts need to be addressed. Both you and the Tories have been running a set of accounts that would make Robert Maxwell blush. No admission in the books to owing anyone any pensions, and yet you take the cash for those pensions. No wonder even you were drastically cutting back on state pensions, but preserving those for people who fund you.

  7. How the OBR’s growth projections have fallen | Left Foot Forward

    […] the OBR’s projection of growth would be 0.9 per cent this year and 0.7 per cent next year. As we feared, this is yet another downgrade from earlier projections, as the chart below […]

  8. Wildey

    Whatever Osborne's growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse: http://t.co/hjwLms6H: writes @danielelton #as12

  9. Alex Braithwaite

    RT @leftfootfwd: Whatever Osborne's growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse http://t.co/fOvWJSqG

  10. OBR confirm Osborne will borrow more than the Darling projection | Left Foot Forward

    […] also: • Whatever Osborne’s growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse – Daniel Elton, November 29th […]

  11. Jamie

    Whatever Osborne’s growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse http://t.co/QfwwBt2c

  12. Newsbot9

    And it gets us 25% unemployment and a B credit rating.

    Great, where do we go from there?

  13. Anonymous

    No it doesn’t. There are many ways of creating jobs in the private sector.

    1. Stop all subsidies.
    2. Remove all illegal migrants.
    3. Change the rules on migrants such that you can only stay if you earn more than 40K [So you pay more tax than the government spends, on average per person]

    Note, 2 and 3 are completely non-racist. It’s a simple test, and nothing to do with ethnicity, etc.

    That frees up lots of low skilled jobs, lots of properties. Hence you don’t need to build so many houses. Instead, the money can be invested in producing things. Services, widgets, ….

    4. Reduce regulations. Makes it more cost effective to employ people – reduces unemployment.

    5. Decrease taxation on investments. That way people who take risks benefit

    6. Stop rent seeking. Getting government to do the dirty work. Corporatism.

    7. Stop all state pensions. Civil service and state pension. However, you have to save. Then, only if the money runs out do the rest of us help. Generates lots of investment money, and that creates jobs.

    So its depends on how you do it.

    However, 7,000 bn in debts on an income of 550 bn. How do you solve that without making the debt problem worse? You can’t. Hit the rich and carry on saying they are scum at the same time, and they will move their assets. They don’t need to move personally.

  14. Osborne proved the doommongers wrong, the economy is even worse | Left Foot Forward

    […] bit of new evidence published since the Compass pamphlet on the £100bn gamble appeared suggests Osborne has […]

  15. Into the Black Labour nails its colours to the OBR - that keeps on getting on wrong | Left Foot Forward

    […] recommendation in this report, however, is its reliance on the Office of Budget Responsibility (OBR).  This report’s naivete on the OBR is strange.  Of course the OBR’s independence is its […]

  16. Borrowing more to borrow less may not be political suicide | Left Foot Forward

    […] also: • Whatever Osborne’s growth forecasts today, the reality is probably worse – Daniel Elton, November 29th […]

Leave a Reply